No Touching At All Manga Reviews (P.12)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 26, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

評判通り

As reputed

とても良いです。何回も繰り返し読んでしまいます。大きな事件とかがあるわけではないのですが、外川さんと嶋さんの心情が伝わってきます。スッピンオフで小野田さんの話もあります。そちらもとても良いです。

It's very good. I read it over and over again. It's not like there was a major incident, but it conveys the feelings of Togawa-san and Shima-san. There is also a story about Mr. Onoda in the spin-off. That one is very good too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 23, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

BL設定を最大限に生かした揺さぶり

Shaking that makes the most of BL settings

This review contains spoilers. ★無口でポーカーフェイスな嶋と遠慮なく踏み込んでくるのにさりげなく優しい上司・外川のオフィスストーリー。★転職初日の嶋が乗ったエレベーターに二日酔いの外川が駆け込んでくる。臭いも最悪、話しも最悪。なのに、いつしか嶋の視線は外川を追っている。嶋の視線と微妙な表情に気付いた外川は、嶋を誘いまくる。惹かれ合いながらも、互いの過去のトラウマに触れることを恐れ踏み出せない嶋と、自分（外川）が言った言葉に捕らわれる嶋と離れた外川。すれ違う2人。嶋の想いは、「どうしても触れたくない」ままなのか…。★間延びした喋り方と相手の可愛くない反応などお構い無しの外川さんに大人の余裕を感じます。嶋くんの素っ気なさに可愛さと愛しさを感じる外川さんに、嶋くんが敵うはずがないなと思います。それでも、自分が傷ついた過去や外川さんの過去を受け止められるほど強くはない嶋くんの葛藤と、「どうしても」に続く言葉が変わる嶋くんの姿に胸打たれます。性的マイノリティへの理解が深まりつつある現代ですが、それでも、男同士であることで不安になること、諦めなくてはならないこともあるという現実を突き付けられます。それを2人で越えていく覚悟と思いやる気持ちは、同性同士に限らないかもしれませんが、やはりBLとしての設定を最大限に生かした揺さぶりだと思いました。★描き下ろし含めて226ページ。セリフのないコマや視線の流れ等で心情が丁寧に表されていると思います。『夜明け前』の「飾らなくていい」と言っていた写真立てに…泣けてしまいます。★作者様の描く煙草を吸うシーンがとても好きです。禁煙失敗もありです。

This review contains spoilers. ★ The office story of Tokawa, who is quiet and has a poker face, and his boss, Togawa, who is casually kind even though he doesn't hesitate to step in. ★ Togawa, who has a hangover, runs into the elevator Shima got on on the first day of her job change. The smell is the worst, and the talk is the worst. Nevertheless, at some point, Shima's gaze is following Togawa. Noticing Shima's gaze and subtle expression, Togawa lures Shima around. Even though they are attracted to each other, Shima is afraid of coming into contact with each other's past trauma, and Tokawa is separated from Shima, who is caught by the words he (Togawa) said. Two people passing by. I wonder if Shima's feelings remain “I really don't want to touch it”... ★ I feel that Togawa-san, who doesn't care about the delayed way of speaking and the other person's uncute reactions, has plenty of room for adulthood. I don't think Shima-kun can match Tokawa-san, who feels cute and lovable in Shima-kun's naivety. Even so, I'm struck by the conflict of Shima-kun, who is not strong enough to accept the past where he was hurt and Mr. Togawa-san's past, and the sight of Shima-kun changing the words that follow “no matter what.” It is a modern age where understanding of sexual minorities is deepening, but even so, we are confronted with the reality that being male makes us anxious and that there are times when we have to give up. The feeling of being prepared and thinking to go beyond that with the two of them may not be limited to people of the same sex, but I still thought it was an act of shaking that made the most of the BL setting. ★ 226 pages including illustrations. I think the feelings are carefully expressed with frames without dialogue, the flow of gaze, etc. The picture frame that said “no need to decorate” from “Before Dawn”... made me cry. ★ I really like the smoking scene drawn by the author. There are also failures to quit smoking.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 19, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

泣ける

I can cry

戸川のとても温かく真っ直ぐな人柄が魅力的。嶋の傷ついた心に優しく染み込んでいく感じがいい。臭いに敏感な私は冒頭の二日酔いの臭いと焼肉とビールとタバコの「ハーッ」は想像したたけで卒倒しそうな位ヤだけれども、それを差し引いてもよいです笑

Togawa's very warm and straight personality is attractive. I like the feeling that it gently soaks into Shima's broken heart. I'm sensitive to odors, and the smell of a hangover at the beginning and the “ha” of yakiniku, beer, and cigarettes are about to the point where I think I'll faint because I had imagined it, but you can subtract that lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 17, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

何回読んでも何回読んでも泣ける

I can cry no matter how many times I read it

購入したのは随分と前です。何度も読みます、そして泣く。切ないです、しかし、大人の冗談ややり取りがほっこりしてて、シリアス要素を軽くしてくれます。スピンオフの「それでも、優しい〜」も何度も読みます。購入してから随分経ち今になってレビュー投稿の理由は、『２つのストーリーのその後を書いて欲しい！』です。作品ファンの方々、声を上げて下さ〜い。お願いします。

I bought it a long time ago. I read it over and over again, and then I cry. It's sad, but adult jokes and interactions make me feel relaxed, and it lightens the serious element. I also read the spin-off “Still, Kind ~” over and over again. It's been a long time since I bought it, and now the reason for posting a review is “I want you to write after the two stories!” That's it. Fans of the work, please raise your voice. please.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 12, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

よすぎ、、、

Yosugi...

ヨネダコウ先生の作品はよんだことがあったのですが、この作品にはまだ手を出せていなくて、他の方のレビューを見て気になったので購入…もう言葉に表せないくらい良かったです！内容も人の感情みたいなのもすごくしっかりしていて、何回も読みたいと思うくらいの作品でした！

There were times when I read Yonedako-sensei's work, but I hadn't tried my hand at this work yet, and I was curious after seeing other people's reviews, so I bought it... it was so good that I can't put it into words anymore! The content and feelings of people were so solid that I wanted to read it over and over again!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 03, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

泣けた…！

I cried...!

外川と嶋、２人の過去、そして今、BLの世界は奥が深いなぁ…。切ない想いが溢れてきます。これ、絶対泣くよね…（泣いたよね…）今、２人が幸せならそれでいい…！この先もずっと２人で幸せに暮らしててほしい…！

The past of Togawa and Shima, and now, the BL world is deep... Sadness overflows. This definitely makes me cry... (I cried...) If the two of them are happy now, that's fine...! I want them to live a happy life together for a long time to come...!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 25, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

レジェンド作品

LEGENDARY WORK

発売当時、紙で読みましたが衝撃がヤバかったです。私の中では伝説的な作品。言葉のチョイスも本当にいいんですよね。ドラマCDも最高！定期的に読みたくなる本！みんな読んでほしいー！！

I read it on paper when it went on sale, but the shock was terrible. It's a legendary work for me. The choice of words is also really good, isn't it? Drama CDs are great too! A book you'll want to read regularly! I want everyone to read it!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 23, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない

It's sad

ずいぶん前に読んでるのにレビューし忘れてました。それでも、やさしい恋をするより断然こっちが好きです。初コミックスでこれって流石…外川さんのさりげない気遣い、嶋くんじゃなくてもぐっときちゃう。嶋くんも外川さんも、辛いことや苦しいことを耐えて頑張ってるからこその優しさや乞う気持ちがあって、恋するってこういうことだよな、と。外川さんの、「もう絶対駄目だと思った…っ」の一言が泣けます！切ない。大好き。

I read it a long time ago, but I forgot to review it. Still, I definitely like this one over having a gentle love. It's my first comic and it's amazing... Togawa-san's casual concern makes me feel so bad even if it's not Shima-kun. Both Shima-kun and Togawa-san have the kindness and feeling of begging because they endure pain and do their best, and this is what falling in love is like. Togawa-san's words, “I thought it was absolutely useless... huh” made me cry! It's sad. I love it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 18, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

さすが

As expected

This review contains spoilers. さすがヨネダコウ先生、って感じのストーリーです。胸がぎゅーーってなります。少し外川さんの自己中っぷりが気になりますが、嶋くんはMっ気があるのかな、こういう人がいいんでしょうね。私は小野田さんの方が好きです。

This review contains spoilers. As expected, it's a story that feels like Yoneda Kou-sensei. It makes my heart ache. I'm a little worried about Togawa-san's self-indulgence, but I wonder if Shima-kun has a sense of masculinity; I think this kind of person would be nice. I like Mr. Onoda better.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 17, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

泣けた

I was able to cry

BLって特に表紙が全てを物語る気がします。ずっと表紙で気になっていたこちら。やっぱりよかった。泣けました。

BL in particular, I feel like the cover says everything. This is the cover I've always been interested in. I'm glad after all. It made me cry.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 15, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

何度読み返したか

How many times have you reread it

何度読み返したかわからないくらい好きな作品です。切なすぎます。泣けます。スピンオフ作品も絶対読むべき！

I love this work so much that I don't know how many times I've reread it. It's too sad. It makes me cry. You should definitely read the spin-off works too!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 04, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

切なかった

I was sad

This review contains spoilers. 過去の辛い失恋から心を閉ざしている嶋を放って置けない外川さん。一見ダメな大人なのに優しいとか素敵か。テーマは重めですが、幸せな結末なので読後感がいいです。

This review contains spoilers. Togawa-san can't let go of Shima, who has closed her heart from her painful heartbreak in the past. Even though they're bad adults at first glance, are they kind or nice? The theme is heavy, but it has a happy ending, so it feels good after reading it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 04, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

大好きな作品です

It's my favorite work

もう何回も何回も何回も何回も読み返しています。とにかく大好きでオススメです。シリアスなのにギャグも多くて絶妙だし、小野田との掛け合いがまた面白いし！出会えて良かった貴重な作品です。個人的には小野田の話の方が好きです。小野田が好きです。

I've already reread it over and over again. Anyway, I love it and recommend it. Even though it's serious, there are a lot of gags and it's exquisite, and the interaction with Onoda is also interesting! It's a valuable work that I'm glad I came across. Personally, I like Onoda's story better. I like Onoda.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 25, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

まさしく保存版ですね

Exactly a preserved version

もう、今更レビューするのが恥ずかしい。。2008年発行から13年。未だ色あせる事がない。どれほど沢山の本を手にとっても、何度も読み返すのは、やはり少ない。こちらはその少ない御本のひとつ。実は、、スピンオフの「それでも、やさしい恋をする」の方が好きなんです。。

I'm already too embarrassed to review it now.. It's been 13 years since it was issued in 2008. The color still hasn't faded. No matter how many books you pick up, there are still few people who reread them over and over again. This is one of those few books. Actually, I like the spin-off “Still, A Tender Love.”

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 24, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない

It's sad

This review contains spoilers. 226ページ。個人的に終始重い印象でした。2人とも過去につらい経験をしているけど真逆のタイプ。一度は別れを選んだけど、引き出しに入ってた煙草で思い出して泣いちゃうシーンは胸がギュッとなりました。つらい過去がある2人にはこれからうんと幸せになってほしいな

This review contains spoilers. page 226. Personally, I had a heavy impression from beginning to end. Both of them have had painful experiences in the past, but they are the exact opposite type. I chose to break up once, but the scene where I remembered the cigarette in the drawer and cried made my heart ache. I want these two people who have a hard past to be so happy from now on

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 14, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ふたりとも幸せにおなり……♦

Both of them are happy to nat... ♦

This review contains spoilers. 好きな作家さんなので購入。嶋の元カレ本当にひどいやつなんだけど、だからこそ外川の対応や言葉が沁みてしまう。外川はなんというか、辛い経験があるのを感じさせない位フランクでフラットなんだけど、やっぱり無理をしていた部分もあるわけで。嶋に対していつも率直に正直に気持ちを伝えるところがすごく好感が持てた。嶋も頑張るって腹をくくったからもう大丈夫。ふたりとも幸せになってくれよー。

This review contains spoilers. It's my favorite writer, so I bought it. Shima's ex-boyfriend is a really terrible guy, but that's why Togawa's responses and words sink in. I mean, Togawa is so frank and flat that it doesn't make me feel like he's had a hard experience, but after all, there are parts where he overdid it. I really liked the fact that she always conveys her feelings openly and honestly to Shima. Shima was hungry because she said she would do her best, so that's fine now. I hope both of them will be happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 12, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

すきだなぁ

I like it

絵もストーリーも好みで、何度読んでも泣けてしまう、、、深いなぁ、、、重いけど、すんごい良かった〜

I like both the pictures and the story, and it makes me cry no matter how many times I read them... it's deep... it's heavy, but it was really good~

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 09, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

受けが好み

I like receiving

期待しすぎて読むのは良くないと思いながらも、これだけのレビュー評価がよいと期待してしまう。ぐるぐる思考の嶋が好みなので、面白かった。初見では、残念ながらストーリーが他と比べて、すごく良いという感じはしなかった。でも、時間を置いて再読すると、ストーリーの良さが実感できます。レンタルではなく、購入をお薦めします。

Even though I think it's not good to expect too much and read it, I expect this much review evaluation to be good. I like the island of round and round thoughts, so it was interesting. At first glance, unfortunately, I didn't feel that the story was really good compared to others. However, if you take a while and reread it, you can feel how good the story is. We recommend purchasing rather than renting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 07, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

買ってよかった！

I'm glad I bought it!

実は手が滑って間違えて購入…でも買って正解でした！お互いに惹かれていく様子が丁寧に書かれてて、感情移入して、夢中で読みました。BL初心者でも楽しめましたよ！

Actually, my hand slipped and made a mistake and bought it... but I bought it and it was correct! It was carefully written about how they are becoming attracted to each other, and I read it with empathy. Even BL beginners enjoyed it!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 28, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

感動！！

Impressed!!

過去に、お互い別の意味でのトラウマがある二人が、ひょんな事から体の関係を持つようになり、、。がさつに見えて実は優しい攻めにどんどん惹かれていくのに、本気になるのが怖い受け。ノンケだったのに、可愛い受けに本気になる攻め。攻めの転勤が決まり、勇気が出なくて別れを選択する受け、、、。でも、結局自分が傷つく事から逃げていると気づき、彼のもとへ、、よかったぁー、めでたしめでたし!(^^)!

In the past, two people who had been traumatized in different meanings began to have a physical relationship by accident... It looks like Gassatsu, and in fact, I'm more and more attracted to gentle attacks, but getting serious is scary. Even though it was a no-go, it was a serious attack due to a cute reception. An aggressive transfer was decided, and they didn't have the courage to choose to part ways... But in the end, I realized that I was running away from getting hurt, and I went to him... thank goodness and congratulations! (^^)!

Helpful

Reviews for No Touching At All Manga