MangaPlaza

Sorry! You need an account to do that! Sign up now to get the most out of your MangaPlaza experience!

Already registered?

All

Romance

MP Originals

Action

Adult Romance

Yuri

Fantasy

Drama

Horror

Harlequin

Light Novels

Find Titles

Search Menu

Search by Genre

Explore Premium

New
Best Sellers
SALE
Coupon
Now Free

Search by Popular Keywords

Others

Search by Author

Special Collections

Back to Title

Reviews for A SOLDIER'S TALE Manga

Overall :

4.5

6 Global Ratings

5 star

50%
4 star

50%
3 star

0%
2 star

0%
1 star

0%

Get This Title

Leave a Review

1 - 6 of 6 Reviews

Sort by

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

Translate All Reviews to English

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 13, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

御伽噺

Otogane

This review contains spoilers. 美女と野獣というかシンデレラというか小公女というか、色んなお話が詰まったようなハーレクインでした。ルイーザはなぜあんなにもピッパに辛辣だったんですかね？最初はハーマイオニがルイーザの娘なんか？と思ったけどドミニクの母親だったし、設定上ハーマイオニがすごい美人で、ピッパが地味ってことなんでしょうか。よく分からないけど、最後にはなぜかみんなピッパの名前書いてサインしてて笑いました。そりゃドミニクは全然紳士じゃないし怒らせたら怖い軍人上がりの子爵だし、これからはピッパのご機嫌も取っておかないとオールダリー家の財産も自由に使えないもんね！笑。まさかのピッパ父まで大金持ちになって帰ってきたのは驚いたけど、欲を言えば結婚式と、領民皆に愛されてたくさん子供に囲まれて暮らしてる姿が見たかったなぁ。

This review contains spoilers. It was a Harlequin filled with a lot of stories, like Beauty and the Beast, or Cinderella, or the Little Princess. Why was Louisa so mean to Pippa? Was Hermione Louisa's daughter in the first place? I thought it was Dominique's mother, and I wonder if that means Hermione is so beautiful in terms of setting that Pippa is plain. I'm not sure, but at the end, for some reason, everyone wrote Pippa's name and signed it, and I laughed. Well, Dominique isn't a gentleman at all, and if you make him angry, he's a viscount rising in the military who's scary, and from now on, you won't be able to freely use the Alderley family's wealth unless you keep Pippa in good spirits! lol. I was surprised that even Pippa's father had become very rich and came back, but speaking of greed, I wanted to see the wedding and how he was loved by everyone in the domain and lived surrounded by many children.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 07, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

ヒーロー

heroes

This review contains spoilers. 身内に対して終始毅然とした態度のヒーローが素敵です。美女と野獣というより小公女かな。

This review contains spoilers. The hero, who has a resolute attitude towards his family from beginning to end, is wonderful. Maybe it's more of a little princess than Beauty and the Beast.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 01, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

美女と野獣

Beauty and the Beast

This review contains spoilers. まさしく美女と野獣心優しいヒロインとヒーローが結ばれて良かった皆のお祝いの気持ちが嬉しい

This review contains spoilers. Exactly Beauty and the Beast I'm glad that the kind-hearted heroine and hero were united, I'm happy everyone's feeling of celebration

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 01, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

よかったよかった

That's good that's good

絵は可愛いし、登場人物もそれぞれ魅力手です。お話もエピソードが多いのにまとまっていて読み応えもあります。最後はうまく行きすぎな感もありますが大団円ということでしょうか。

The pictures are cute, and the characters are all charming. Even though the story has a lot of episodes, it's organized and worth reading. There is also a feeling that things didn't go too well at the end, but I wonder if that means it's a big group yen.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 25, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

クリスマスもの

Christmas stuff

同じ原作の「伯爵からの招待状」に酷似していて、宿り木や12夜の劇、プロポーズの失敗、確固たる居場所の無いヒロインと貴族という設定までも同じ。他の方のコメント通り登場人物の心情が浅くて表面的に進んでしまうのが残念！でも健気で優しい女の子をちゃんと見ている周囲の人々やヒーローと言うのは嬉しくなる設定で大好きだから高め評価で。それにしてもヒーローと妹はマトモなのに母親は意地が悪いのは不思議。なんであんなにヒロインを邪険にするのか分からなかった。

It's very similar to “The Invitation from the Earl” from the same original story, and the setting of Yuki, the Twelfth Night play, the failed proposal, and the heroine and aristocrat with no firm place is the same. As others have commented, it's a pity that the characters' feelings are so shallow that it progresses superficially! But the people and heroes around me who are properly watching the healthy and kind girl are highly rated because I love it in a setting that makes me happy. Even so, it's strange that the mother is mean even though the hero and younger sister are matomo. I didn't understand why they would make the heroine so evil.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 21, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

もう少し欲しいけど

I want a little more

This review contains spoilers. 登場人物は確かに多いし、もう少し説明になるページが欲しいのはあるけど、クリスマスに善良な乙女が幸せになる話としてはありかなぁ…と思います。もう少し、野獣としての苦悩とかすれ違い感とかあってくれたら読みごたえあったかな？って感じで、あと、せっかくキスシーンがどうこうと言ってたので、舞台でそれをしてほしかったな。と個人的に。ヒロインをちゃんと助けて守ってくれるヒーローで良かったです。

This review contains spoilers. There are certainly a lot of characters, and I would like a page that explains a little more, but I wonder if there is a story where a good maiden is happy at Christmas... Wouldn't it have been worth reading if you had a little more of a sense of anguish and confusion as a wild beast? It felt like, and they said how the kiss scene would be, so I wanted them to do it on stage. and personally. I'm glad he was a hero who properly helped and protected the heroine.

Helpful

Leave a Review