All I Ever Did Was Love You Manga Reviews

Noir

Report

Apr 03, 2025 (PST) | Total Reviews: 60

Captivatingly awful

I cannot describe how awful this manga is beginning to end, especially the end. There’s so much wrong with it. After reading manga for over 18 years and reading some terrible stuff this is somehow in my top ten worst mangas I’ve ever read. However, it’s drama and it’s captivating. You feel bad for the FL and antagonist, you understand why they are the way they are. You feel angry and sad and so many emotions for everyone. That’s probably why it’s in my top ten worst. It was full of cliche tropes but also not. I’m literally sitting here with my husband mad at him for no reason and also screaming at him explaining what happened. It’s good. It’s so awfully good. If you want some fudged up stuff read it.

Helpful

(3)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 01, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

最後の終わり方が……

The way it ended at the end...

This review contains spoilers. サスペンス的な作品。どんどん引き込まれて読んでしまった。ヒロインには幸せになってほしかった。ほんとに好きな人と色々あって元の鞘にもどって良かったと安心したのにあの終わり方は何？エッーって感じです！どっちが刺されちゃったのかわからない終わり方…読みてに任せるっていうことでしょうか……。

This review contains spoilers. Suspenseful work. I was drawn more and more into reading it. I wanted the heroine to be happy. There were a lot of people I really liked, and I was relieved that I was glad I went back to the original scabbard, but how did that end? Eh, it feels like! I don't know which one got stabbed and how it ended... I guess I'll leave it up to you...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 04, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

複雑な気持ちになる作品

Works that make you feel mixed

胸が痛くなるのに、何度も読み返してしまう。全員の心情に寄り添える。良い意味でも悪い意味でも。読後、すごい考えさせられた。結末にはすごく腹が立つのに、でも結局すごく好き。良く出来た作品だと思います。

My heart hurts, but I reread it over and over again. It is close to everyone's feelings. Both in a good way and in a bad way. It made me think a lot after reading it. I was really angry at the ending, but I really liked it after all. I think it's a well-made work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 17, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

Endの文字に泣いた

I cried at the letters End

気が狂って笑うみやと、青ざめて泣き叫ぶかずほ、倒れて動かない血だらけのわたる、、みたいなしょぼい想像力しかないので、誰か続きを下さい‥。

There is nothing but shabby imagination like Mad Laughing, Kazuho who turns pale and cries, and Bloody Wataru who falls down and doesn't move, so please continue...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 05, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

強烈です。

It's intense.

This review contains spoilers. 兎に角物凄く強烈です。最初からほぼ最後までドロドロ…切ないのは航が「和穂が俺を捨てれるまでそばにいる」のコメント…航の浮気が原因だけど。究極の裏切りの浮気を少しでも許すには同等の何かを失くさないと無理と知った航の退職。やっとお互い少し幸せになれるかのところで最後の飛んでもないエンディング…まぁ読んでてしんどくなるくらい強烈です。お奨めです。

This review contains spoilers. Rabbits and horns are really strong. Muddy from beginning to almost the end... the sad thing is Wataru's comment “I'll be by your side until Kazuho abandons me”... it's because of Wataru's affair. Wataru learned that in order to forgive even a little bit of the ultimate betrayal, it was impossible to lose something equal, and retired. The final unfinished ending where we can finally be a little happy with each other... well, it's so intense that it becomes difficult to read. I recommend it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 03, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

読後感、ハンパなく悪し

The feeling after reading is bad because it doesn't hurt

This review contains spoilers. 自分の節操のなさを彼女のトラウマのせいにするなよな〜。あれこれ言っても結局、関係を持つのが、嫌そうでない…何回するつもりだ。心と体は別…の範疇を超えてます。素敵なイラストに見合ったハッピーエンドにならないかと考えてみても、この男を許せる気がしなくて、すごくモヤモヤしてました。最後まで読んで、一瞬、幸せになる方がよかったのに…と思ったけど、読み返したら、航の行動に改めてイライラして「どんな罰でも受ける」と本人が言ってた天誅が降っただけかもとも思いました…浮気の罰にしては重すぎるけど。結婚してる訳でもない男の裏切りになんでこんなにイライラするのだろう。航から、和穂を失いたくないと言う必死さを感じられないからなんだと思った。恐れているのは、和穂の新たなトラウマの原因に自分がなる事。自分のせいでリストカットされる事…だけ。悪者になる事だけ。だから、最後と言われて、簡単にあんな風に名前呼びながら自分から腕を回してできるんだな。そして、ものすごく薄〜い自己嫌悪。もっと許して欲しいと必死にならんのか。ほんとは和穂の事、さして好きじゃないのでは。航がどうなったかで、お腹に赤ちゃんがいる和穂がどうなってしまうのかだけが心配です。何も悪い事してないのに、馬鹿な男が彼氏だったばかりに可哀想だ。

This review contains spoilers. Don't blame her for her trauma for her lack of discipline. No matter how many times I say this and that, in the end, they don't seem to hate having a relationship... I plan to do it many times. Mind and body are beyond the category of different... Even when I thought about the happy ending commensurate with the wonderful illustration, I didn't feel like I could forgive this man, and I was really confused. I read it until the end, and for a moment, I thought it would have been better to be happy... but when I reread it, I was once again frustrated by Wataru's actions and originally thought that Tenchū, who himself said “I can receive any kind of punishment,” had just fallen... it's too heavy a punishment for cheating, though. I wonder why they are so frustrated by the betrayal of a man who isn't even married. I thought it was because Wataru couldn't feel the desperation to say he didn't want to lose Kazuho. What I'm afraid of is that I will become the cause of Kazuho's new trauma. it's just that my list gets cut because of myself... It's just about being the bad guy. That's why they say it's the last one, and you can easily turn your arms around yourself while calling them names like that. Also, extremely weak self-loathing. Aren't you desperately wanting more forgiveness? Actually, I don't think they really like Kazuho. I'm only worried about what happened to Wataru and what will happen to Kazuho, who has a baby in his stomach. It's a pity that even though I haven't done anything wrong, that stupid man just had my boyfriend.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 26, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

読まない方が良かった

It was better not to read

This review contains spoilers. 読んだことを後悔する最悪の終わり方でした。ツライ過去を乗り越えて、それぞれに幸せを見つけられると思ったのに。自分にも幸せになれるチャンスがあったのに、やっぱり人の幸せは許せない？何の希望も持てないラストでした。

This review contains spoilers. It was the worst way to end up regretting reading it. I thought we could overcome our difficult past and find happiness for each of us. You had a chance to be happy yourself, but you still can't forgive people's happiness? It was the last one where I had no hope.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 30, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

過去最高にイライラした

I was the most frustrated ever

This review contains spoilers. かもしれないです。こんなに漫画にイライラしたこと未だかつてあったかな？ってくらい。震えそうでした。他の方のレビューで見た最初の一回を謝るで済んだことだと思います。自分なら一回でも許さんかもしれんけど。にしても最悪な選択繰り返しすぎだしミヤに過去どんな酷いことがあっても絶対今後も不幸にしかなってほしくない。もう絶対かずほたちが戻るルートが見えないしさっさと別れてかずほだけが幸せになってほしい。かずほの幸せ見届けたいので続きが早く読みたいです。彼氏マジでありえない。

This review contains spoilers. It might be. Have you ever been so frustrated with comics before? That's about it. I almost shivered. I think I just apologized for the first time I saw it in other people's reviews. If it were me, I might not be able to forgive it even once. Even so, the worst choices have been repeated too many times, and no matter what terrible things have happened to Miya in the past, I definitely don't want her to be nothing but unhappy in the future. I just want Kazuho to break up quickly because they can't see the route Kazuho and the others will return anymore and only Kazuho will be happy. I want to watch Kazuho's happiness, so I want to read the continuation as soon as possible. I seriously can't have a boyfriend.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 23, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

クソ男が不幸になればいい

It would be nice if the damn man was unhappy

This review contains spoilers. 結婚まで考えてそうな誠実な彼氏かと思ったら、ヒロインの過去知ってて、浮気に気を取られるクソ男。でも、別れてもヒロインだけが前に進むのが怖くなってる状態でクソ男は進める状況なのがモヤモヤする(๑-﹏-๑)新しい道探した方がお互い明るい未来の可能性が高い気がする....他の人のレビュー見て、意外とみんな男の浮気に関して寛容なんだなぁと思った。ことクソ男の浮気に関しては一時レベルの過ちじゃないと思うけど...ヒロイン支える気がないなら退場して欲しい( ･᷅ὢ･᷄ )

This review contains spoilers. When I thought he was a sincere boyfriend who seemed to be thinking about marriage, this damn man knows about the heroine's past and is distracted by cheating on her. However, it's a situation where the damn man is fearful that only the heroine will move forward even after breaking up is confusing (--)) and I feel that there is a high possibility that they will both have a brighter future with each other... I looked at other people's reviews, and surprisingly, I thought that everyone is tolerant when it comes to men cheating on them. I don't think it's a momentary mistake when it comes to this damn man's affair, but... if you don't feel like supporting the heroine, I want you to leave (･･･)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 27, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

まじか？

seriously?

This review contains spoilers. あまりにもリアルです。入り込みすぎて怖いけどやっぱりみてしまいます。どの登場人物の気持ちもわかるから何だかせつなくて。これからの続きリアルでよろしくです。

This review contains spoilers. It's just too real. It's scary because it gets in too much, but I still watch it. I can understand the feelings of every character, so it was unbearable. Best regards for the continuation of the real world from now on.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 23, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

怖い?でも面白い

scared? But it's interesting

気になって一気に読んでしまいました。内容はとても面白くて、引き込まれます。しかし、友人の存在が。。。?主人公は何も悪くない。幸せになって欲しい！ヒーローも魔が差してしまって泥沼?だけど、救われて欲しい?続き気になる作品です！

I was curious and read it all at once. The content is very interesting and engaging. But the presence of friends...? There's nothing wrong with the main character. I want them to be happy! Heroes are also in a quagmire because demons have struck them? but do you want to be saved? It's a work I'm still interested in!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 04, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

色んな過去があるにしても

Even if they have many pasts

ここまでの執着は何？と思ってしまうくらいドロドロです。浮気して脅されたにしても何回もだと自分の意思だろ！って思っちゃいますけど！最後もあの終わり方に胸糞覚えたので☆1つ減らしました。

What's your obsession up to this point? It's so muddy that it makes me think. Even if you cheat and get threatened over and over again, it's probably your own intention! That makes me think! I also felt heartbroken at the end that way it ended, so I reduced it by 1 ☆.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 03, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろかったー

That was interesting

ドロドロ好きにはたまりませんミヤの言うとおり男は性欲には逆らえん人が多いかもしれんけど(実際たまってる時にあんな誘われ方したら私が男でもいくとおもうし笑)航は誠実なふりしてる分イライラが何倍もにもなる浮気もしょっぱなからアオカンだわ和穂レイプするわでくそ中のくそそんなわけで課金がとまりませんでした

It's irresistible for mudoro lovers, as Miya said, there are probably a lot of men who can't go against sexual desire (in fact, if I'm invited that way when I'm stuck up lol) Wataru pretends to be sincere, and his flirtatious affair is so salty it's so bad he rapes Kazuho, damn it, that's why the charges didn't stop

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 22, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

最終話は読んでない

I haven't read the last episode

This review contains spoilers. 他のレビューを見たら最後はモヤっとするらしいので妄想するに止める笑。ミヤの罠に嵌められてある意味被害者なのかもしれないけど最初はノリノリだったし結局性欲に負けてるから航に天罰が下ってくれ！！和穂はツラい過去があるのにその過去のせいで追い討ちかけられて可哀想だったな。是非この先は素敵な人と出会ってくれ！！この手のジャンルは主人公のパートナーの苦しんでいくところが醍醐味だと思ってるから航が体調崩したり仕事ダメになったり苦悩してるところが最高に良かった！持ち上げて落とす！良い！！拍手！！！友達ちゃんに言われてたことが航の本質なんだと思った。でも和穂をレ◯プするくだりからは？？？だった。更なる鬱展開だったり軽蔑するかと思ったけど。。。自分の中でキリ良く終わらせたかったので最終話はレビューを見て終わらせて頂きました笑

This review contains spoilers. When I saw the other reviews, they seemed to be confused at the end, so I stopped being delusional lol. Caught in Miya's trap, she may be a victim in a sense, but at first she was nervous, and in the end, she gave in to her sexual desires, so God punish Wataru!! Kazuho has a rough past, but it was a pity that they were being hunted down because of that past. Please meet wonderful people in the future!! I think the real thrill of this kind of genre is that the main character's partner is suffering, so the best part was that Wataru is in pain from getting sick or ruined at work! Lift it up and drop it! good!! applause!!! I thought what my friend was telling me was the essence of Wataru. but from where Kazuho gets screwed??? It was. I thought it would be a further development of depression or disdain... I wanted to finish the final episode in a good mood, so I watched the reviews and finished the final episode lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 25, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

イライラと安心

Frustration and relief

最初、イライラしながらでも気になって最後まで読みました。ずぅーとイライラがおさまらなくて最後の方安心したかと思ったけど、最後の最後どうなったのか！続きが気になる形で終わってしまって少しショック！

Even though I was frustrated at first, I was curious and read it until the end. My frustration didn't subside the whole time, and I thought I was relieved towards the end, but what happened at the very end! I was a little shocked that it ended in such a way that I was worried about the continuation!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 17, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

買って損した最終巻

The last volume I bought and lost

This review contains spoilers. ようやく幸せになれると楽しみにしてたのにこれかい浮気はホント許せないし罰を受けるべきだけどこれはない因果応報にしてもちょっとね刺されたけど助かって相手は精神病院で壊れるとかそこまでやってくれないと2人のツケを主人公が払ったんじゃないかすっきり終わって欲しかった14巻まで楽しんで読んでただけに終わり方が残念でしかたないでも途中までハラハラドキドキしてたので星は4つです。

This review contains spoilers. I was looking forward to finally being happy, but I was really unforgivable and should be punished, but even if there was no causal retaliation, I was stabbed a little bit but saved, and my opponent broke down in a mental hospital or if they didn't go that far, I enjoyed reading up to volume 14, which I wanted to finish clearly, so the ending was unfortunate and unavoidable, but I was thrilled halfway through, so it's 4 stars.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 20, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

くせになる

It becomes addictive

一気に読み進めました。読後感は本当に悪いんだけど、続きが気になって、、ヒロインが少しずつでも前に進めたらいいな。

I read it all at once. The feeling after reading is really bad, but I'm worried about the continuation... it would be nice if the heroine could move forward little by little.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 02, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

怖すぎる

It's too scary

ミヤが、怖すぎる闇抱えすぎ…。ミヤにかかわらなければ、幸せになれたかもしれないのに…。誰も幸せになれなさそうで、どう終わるのか、気になりすぎる。

Miya has too much fear and too much darkness... If I hadn't gotten involved with Miya, I might have been happy... Nobody seems to be happy, and I'm too worried about how it will end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 28, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

欲望を我慢できない最低な男

The worst man who can't stand his desires

This review contains spoilers. 最初から名前を呼んで快楽を共有したことも繰り返してるのも許せない！罪悪感に負けて浮気を隠し通すことも出来ないし...潜在意識に彼女が重荷になっていたからプロポーズしなかったんでしょ。別れてから浮気すれば！結果的に新たなトラウマを抱えさせて心を暗闇に染めるように導いてるし「どんなことしても償う」それは自己満足で彼女のためじゃないし「俺を捨てられるときがくるまで」って...彼女から離れていくことによって犯した過ちから楽になりたいだけ悲観ぶってる。高校の先生みたいに数年後、新しい恋をして幸せになる未来があるなら許せない！別れに向かってカウントダウンが始まった？その過程が描かれるのなら、予測不能な展開を期待するしかない

This review contains spoilers. I can't forgive them for calling them by name from the beginning and sharing their pleasures over and over again! I can't hide my affair because I gave in to my sense of guilt... and I guess they didn't propose because she was a burden to my subconscious mind. Let's have an affair after we break up! As a result, she had a new trauma and led her to dye her heart dark, and “I'll make amends no matter what you do” it's not for her because of complacency, and “until the time comes when she abandons me”... I'm pessimistic just because I want to feel better from the mistakes I made by moving away from her. If there is a future where you have a new love and be happy in a few years like your high school teacher, I can't forgive you! Has the countdown started for parting ways? If that process is to be depicted, there is no choice but to expect unpredictable developments

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 24, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

可哀想すぎる

That's too pathetic

This review contains spoilers. この性悪女糞すぎてビックリする。こんな女と浮気して後悔してるのにも関わらず最後に抱いて欲しいと言われ簡単に抱くって全然反省もしてないし和穂傷つけたの後悔してるなら最後にって言われても普通断るやろ。いい彼氏なんかやなくてただの浮気男やん。性悪女に制裁をお願いします。過去にも色々やらかして人傷つけてるやつにのほほんと生きて欲しくない。和穂の苦しみ以上の苦しみを味わえばいい！わたるも和穂裏切った罰は受けるべき。一生後悔の年に苛まれて生きていけ。和穂の幸せ願ってます！

This review contains spoilers. I'm surprised that this wicked woman is so stupid. Despite having an affair with a woman like this and regretting it, they say they want her to be hugged last, and they don't have any remorse at all, and if they regret hurting Kazuho, they'll usually refuse even if they say it's the last time. he doesn't have a good boyfriend, he's just a cheating man. Please punish naughty women. I really don't want someone who has hurt people by doing a lot of things in the past to live alone. You should experience more suffering than Kazuho's! Watarumo should be punished for betraying Kazuho. Live your whole life tormented by years of regrets. I wish Kazuho happiness!

Helpful

Reviews for All I Ever Did Was Love You Manga