Pumpkin Scissors

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Mar 16, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English
  台詞のセンスがずば抜けてる
  The sense of dialogue is outstanding
  キャラ造形ネームセンス世界観設定どれも良い戦記物系好きな人ならおすすめ（これは戦記物してるわけではないけど）カルロゼン原作ものが好きな人なら多分絶対はまる

  Character modeling, name sense, and worldview settings are all good, recommended for people who like war records (although this isn't war chronicles), if you like the original Carlozen story, you'll probably definitely fall in love with it

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Aug 16, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English
  祝！ 連載再開！！
  Congrats! Serialization resumed!!
  祝、24巻発売。アニメから入って、続きが読みたくて原作を、休載を知りながらも23巻まで購入、半ば、諦めながらも、今回の再開、ありがとうございます。

  Congratulations, volume 24 is on sale. I started with the anime, bought up to 23 volumes even though I knew it was suspended, and even though I had given up, thank you for resuming the original story this time.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Jul 03, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English
  とても奥が深い作品
  A very profound work
  戦争のその後、「戦災」という後遺症に立ち向かう部隊の活躍を描いたストーリーだが、体一つで戦車を倒すという常人離れした戦闘力を持つ大男が加わり、戦争とは、正義とは、愛とは、人の格差とは・・・などなど、考えさせられるテーマの話が展開される。その男のかつての所属部隊には秘密があり、それも物語の軸となっている。一度連載が中断していたが、この度めでたく再開（４年ぶり）。現在、文字が大変多く、「難しい漫画」になっている印象が否めないが、正義とは・・・理想の世界とは・・・十分我々の現実に必要な思考であると思われるし、相当作りこまれている作品として価値が高いと感じる。アリスがかっけえ伍長がかわいいという見方でも楽しめるので色んな人が読めばいいと思います。

  After the war, it is a story depicting the activities of forces confronting the sequelae of “war disaster,” but a big man with combat power far from normal people, such as defeating chariots with one body, joins, and stories with themes that make you think about war, justice, love, human disparity... etc., unfold. There is a secret about the unit that man used to belong to, and that is also the axis of the story. Serialization was interrupted once, but now it has resumed (first time in 4 years). Currently, there are so many characters, and I cannot deny the impression that it is a “difficult comic,” but justice... an ideal world... seems to be an idea necessary enough for our reality, and I feel that it is highly valuable as a work that has been created quite a bit. It can also be enjoyed from the perspective that Alice is cool and Corporal is cute, so I think it would be nice if many people could read it.

  Helpful