Umineko WHEN THEY CRY Episode 8: Twilight of the Golden Witch

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Dec 20, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English
  読んでほしい
  I want you to read
  This review contains spoilers. 一度原作を離れた方も、是非最後まで読んでほしいです。戦人は帰ってこないと真実で語られていたので覚悟はしていましたがそれでも自分はとても納得できた結末でした。それぞれの罪、思い、約束がわかりやすく書かれています。

  This review contains spoilers. Even if you have left the original story once, I definitely want you to read it to the end. It was said in truth that the warriors would not return, so I was prepared, but even so, I was very satisfied with the ending. Each sin, thought, and promise is written in an easy-to-understand manner.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Aug 30, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English
  シリーズ8
  series 8
  This review contains spoilers. シリーズ8作目で本編最後のエピソードです。今回は縁寿のアフターケアのようなストーリーで、縁寿の為に最期まで真実を胸に仕舞い込んだ絵羽さんの印象が大きく変わりました。金蔵と右代宮家の兄弟の中で一番情のある人は彼女だったなと思います。寂しいラストでした。

  This review contains spoilers. This is the eighth film in the series and the last episode of the main story. This time it's a story like Enju's Aftercare, and the impression of Eha, who kept the truth in her heart until the end of her life for Enju, changed drastically. Among the siblings of the Kanazo and Udaimiya family, I think she was the most affectionate person. It was a lonely last.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Sep 27, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English
  猫箱に最も深く触れられる
  Can you touch the cat box the most deeply
  This review contains spoilers. うみねこは原作、アニメ、ゲームまで広く展開していますが、もっとも真実を知りたがる「山羊」の皆様には絶対に漫画がおすすめです！！！正直うみねこの終わり方ってモヤモヤしますよね…！！私も初めて出会った時は理解できず、最後まで作品を追いかけることができませんでした…しかしうみねこという作品自体が「真実を追いかける物語でない」ことに気づくと、あのモヤっとした終わり方も許せるはずです。そして漫画ではどうして真実を追いかけてはならないのかの答えが示されています！これを読めるようにしてくれた竜騎士先生と夏海先生に深く感謝！過去の裏側まで見れてようやくうみねこを完走できたと思えます！！漫画版めちゃくちゃおすすめです！！！

  This review contains spoilers. Umineko has developed a wide range of original works, anime, and games, but I definitely recommend comics to everyone who wants to know the truth!!! Honestly, the way Umineko ends is confusing...!! When I first met him, I couldn't understand it, and I wasn't able to follow the work until the end... but when I realized that the work called Umineko itself was “not a story about chasing the truth,” you can forgive that fuzzy way it ended. And in comics, the answer to why we shouldn't chase the truth is shown! I am deeply grateful to Dragonriders and Natsumi sensei for making it possible for me to read this! I think I was finally able to finish Umineko after seeing the other side of the past!! I really recommend the manga version!!!

  Helpful