MATT CALDWELL: TEXAS TYCOON

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Aug 26, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English
  ホントに良かった
  I'm really glad
  This review contains spoilers. 訳あり過去だろうなとすぐにわかる的確な描写に感服。ヒーローの最初の頃のヒロインを追い込むやり方には腹が立つ思いだったけど後半の辛い過去を忘れさせる解決方法ではなく、未来のための進展ある解決法をやりとげさせた辺りから彼の株は急上昇。結婚式で終わるのでなく、最後にイジワルされた女性や、服役を終えたお母さんなど本当の円満解決でアッパレでした。美しい絵がグイグイ引き込んでくれて一気に読めて最高でした！

  This review contains spoilers. I'm impressed by the accurate depiction that immediately makes it clear that the translation is in the past. I was infuriated by the way the hero pushed in the heroine at the beginning, but it wasn't a solution that made me forget the painful past of the latter half, and his stock skyrocketed from the point where he made progress in solutions for the future come to fruition. It didn't end with a wedding, but it was a true amicable settlement for the woman who was bullied at the end of the day and the mother who finished serving time in prison. The beautiful pictures drew me in and it was great to be able to read them all at once!

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Aug 25, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English
  テーマは重い
  The theme is heavy
  This review contains spoilers. 他人の痛みを思いやれないヒーローには腹が立ちましたが、ドクターに相談に行って自分の間違いを認めたのでよしとします。結婚後の幸せそうな様子もとても良かった。

  This review contains spoilers. I was angry at the hero who couldn't care for other people's pain, but I went to talk to the doctor and acknowledged my mistake, so I'm fine. The happy appearance after marriage was also very nice.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Oct 12, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English
  星合先生に感服
  I admire Hoshiai-sensei
  いつもハーレはコミックから原作に入るのだが、始めて原作から入った作品。正直、原作が好き過ぎて、あの世界観を壊されたくなかったので、なかなかコミックには手が出せなかったのだが、星合先生だったので思い切って購入。前半のヒーローの傍若無人っぷりが際立つ程、後半の庇護欲に目覚めるヒーローの甘さが活きてくるので、原作に比べるとまだおとなしめではあるものの、想像以上に良かった。また、あのボリュームと内容の濃さをどう纏めるのかがポイントの一つだと思っていたが、ページ数も通常より多少長くしてあり違和感なく進行していたし、最低限外してほしくないシーンがしっかり残っていて、私的には大満足。個人的には水鉄砲と、ダブルヒーローかと思うくらい重要ポジを占めているヒーロー従兄弟がお気に入り(笑)先生オリジナルのヒーローの本名の出し方も素敵。また原作が読みたくなってきた。

  Harle is always based on comics, but this is the first work to start with the original story. To be honest, I liked the original story so much that I didn't want that worldview destroyed, so I couldn't get my hands on comics, but since it was Hoshiai-sensei, I took the plunge and bought it. The more the hero in the first half stands out, the more the sweetness of the hero who awakens to the desire for protection in the second half comes to life, so although it is still quiet compared to the original story, it was better than I had imagined. Also, I thought one of the points was how to summarize that volume and intensity of content, but the number of pages was slightly longer than normal, so it progressed without any sense of incongruity, and there were plenty of scenes I didn't want to miss at least, so I'm personally very satisfied. Personally, I like water guns and my hero cousins, who occupy such an important position that I think they are double heroes (laughs), and the way the real names of the original heroes come up is also wonderful. I'm starting to want to read the original story again.

  Helpful