PRINCESS'S SECRET BABY

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Jan 18, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English
  正しい家出
  The right run away from home
  散文詩でも読んだように読み終えた。まるで実験のような方法で物語は独特の紡ぎ方。ハーレクインの表紙買いもそもそも初めて。感性豊かに二人が描かれ、そこから既にみなみ先生ワールドは始まっていた。親が子を愛していない家庭。ヒロインは地獄から飛び出し、それは冒険以外の何物でもなかったけれども、HQだから幸せに着地した。心の内を語る手法を取るとそこは映像化は厳しいが、エピソードが俯瞰される形で突き放し味わいを出している。ただ、こういう形式を好まぬ読者は居るかもしれない。相手の気持ちをつかみきれず、信じきれず。二人は疑心暗鬼の中に互いへの感情を内に抱えて、二人を繋ぐ「一夜」がその後の一切の振り出しとなる。「賭けた」訳ではなかったろうが、「未来のかかった」一夜に、なった。チャラ男としか思われない彼が、ただ一人、ヒロインを、愛を注がない家族という地獄から、王宮の冷たさから、保守的な国の生殺しの檻から、ヒロインを愛情によって手を差し伸べた奇跡の脱出劇なのだ。それも、相手の登場のない舞台の台詞劇のようにモノローグでの言葉が躍動し、みなみ先生の繰り出す現実が隣に有りながら、二人以外は全員単なる舞台装置よろしく、関わり合いを無機的に仕上げている。なかなかないポジションにいる作品だと思う。人物以外が描かれていなさ過ぎの、頁スカスカのHQ作品は相当多い。そんなレベルの作品と同一価格で販売され、同じ対価の割合で印税を得ているのだとしたら、この作家の労力には不公平なような気がしてくる。管理の厳しいところはレイラのようなことは不思議ではない。私達の国に於いても、そこの立場の彼らは、我々の当たり前はほぼ経験できないという想像を越えた窮屈と、堅固な外界との隔壁と遮断とがある。庶民の我々なら誰もが知っていることは、我々は日頃自由に何気なく享受出来ているという「普通の」市民生活から我々が得られたものだ。HQ的な極端設定の中に、お話の世界だからこその思いきりもあるが、ここはあながち見当違いのリアリティー欠如とも言い切れないと思う。超音波での胎内撮影写真は、見たところで一体どこが何であるか判らないものだと思っていた。

  I finished reading it as if I had read it in prose poetry. The story is a unique way of spinning in an experimental way. This is my first time buying a Harlequin cover. Two people were drawn with a rich sense of emotion, and Minami Sensei World had already begun from there. A family where parents don't love their children. The heroine jumped out of hell, and although it was nothing but an adventure, she landed happily because it's HQ. If you take the method of talking about the heart, the visualization is tough, but the episode is thrown out in a form where a bird's-eye view is taken to bring out the flavor. However, there may be readers who don't like this kind of format. I couldn't grasp the other person's feelings, and I couldn't believe it. The two have feelings for each other in the midst of doubt and dark demons, and “One Night,” which connects the two, becomes the beginning of everything after that. It probably wasn't a “bet,” but it became “the future took” overnight. It's a miraculous escape drama where he, thought of only as a chara man, reached out to the heroine with love from the hell of a family with no love, from the coldness of the royal palace, from the cage of life and death in a conservative country, to the heroine with love. Also, the words in the monologue move like a stage line drama where no opponent appears, and while the reality presented by Minami sensei is next to each other, everyone except the two is just a stage set, and the relationship is finished inorganically. I think it's a work that's in a bad position. There are quite a few HQ works with pages that don't depict anything other than people. If it were sold at the same price as a work of that level, and royalties were obtained at the same rate of consideration, it would be unfair to this artist's labor. It's no wonder that things are hard to manage like Leila. Even in our country, they are in a position where they have tightness beyond imagination that we can hardly experience for granted, and a strong barrier and blockage from the outside world. What all of us common people know is that we have gained from a “normal” civic life where we are able to enjoy freely and casually on a daily basis. In an extreme HQ-like setting, there is also a feeling that is only in the world of the story, but I don't think this can be said that there is such a misplaced lack of reality. I thought the prenatal photos taken with ultrasound were something I couldn't tell exactly where what was when I saw them.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Aug 01, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English
  絵が好き
  I like painting
  This review contains spoilers. いろいろなすれ違いがあってすごく切ない感じだったけど、不誠実なことはしてなくて良かったです。家族がクソすぎただけ。絵が本当に好きです、イケメンだし、美人だし綺麗。

  This review contains spoilers. There were so many misunderstandings that it felt really sad, but I'm glad I wasn't being dishonest. My family was just too damn bad. I really like the picture, he's handsome, beautiful, and beautiful.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Dec 08, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English
  シリーズ？
  series?
  This review contains spoilers. サクサクと話が進みますが、ヒロインの両親は一体何をしているのかという疑問が残ります。お国は大丈夫なのでしょうか。国を出てきたヒロインを優しく守るヒーローに救われます。これはチャッツフィールドシリーズの一つなのでしょうか。

  This review contains spoilers. The conversation progresses quickly, but the question of what exactly the heroine's parents are doing remains. Is the country OK? You are saved by a hero who gently protects the heroine who left the country. Is this part of the Chatsfield series?

  Helpful