Sherlock Bones

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  May 09, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English
  犬と人間の名コンビ！
  A famous combination of dogs and humans!
  あの名探偵が犬に、という設定が面白い。助手となった尊もさわやかな好感持てるキャラで、事件を解決していくのが読んでて楽しい。あと、とにかく犬のシャードックが可愛いです。画担当や原作の先生が犬を好きなんだろうな、て伝わってくる。たぶんPCじゃなくペン手描きかな？瞳や毛並み、仕草や動きとか丁寧に描いてあって、中身が人の設定を上手く表現してます。特に1巻のシャードックがパイプ吸うカットは渾身というか、やられます(^^) ホームズのライバル、モリアーティ教授もまさかの姿で出てきて受けました。成長した尊の話も面白かった。完結したの残念だけど、また続編出ないかな。

  The setting where the detective is turned into a dog is interesting. Takeru, who became an assistant, is also a refreshing and likeable character, and it's fun to read about solving incidents. Also, anyway, the dog Shardock is cute. It is conveyed that the person in charge of painting and the teacher who wrote the original story probably likes dogs. Maybe it's hand-drawn with a pen and not a PC? The eyes, coat, gestures, and movements are carefully drawn, and the contents express the person's settings well. In particular, the cut in volume 1 where Shardock smokes a pipe is done with his whole body (^^) Holmes' rival, Professor Moriarty, also came out unexpectedly and received it. The story of Takeru, who grew up, was also interesting. It's a pity that it's finished, but I wonder if there will be another sequel.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Sep 11, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English
  探偵漫画！
  Detective comics!
  This review contains spoilers. ちゃんとトリックやタネなどがありそれを主人公とペットの犬が解き明かしていく某コ○ンのような感じの漫画です絵が綺麗で見やすくかかれていてなかなかいいと思います

  This review contains spoilers. It's a comic like a certain comic where there are tricks and seeds, etc., and the main character and pet dog unravel them. I think it's pretty nice that the pictures are beautiful and easy to read

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Aug 07, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English
  倒叙ミステリー
  Glee Mysteries
  This review contains spoilers. 読者には最初から犯人が知らされていて、主人公がどうやって犯人を追い詰めるのかを描いていきます。ホームズが犬のため、主人公は学校や職場、病院などあらゆるところに犬を連れ込む必要がああり、そこが非現実的すぎて気になりました。もっと小さくてポケットに忍ばせてもバレない虫やトカゲ、小鳥やハムスターとかなら良かったんですが…。シャードックの謎に関する伏線も未回収で第一部完となっていますが、第二部ができるほど人気は無かったということでしょうか。

  This review contains spoilers. Readers are informed of the culprit from the beginning, and we will depict how the protagonist hunts down the culprit. Since Holmes is a dog, the main character needs to bring dogs everywhere, such as schools, workplaces, hospitals, etc., and I was worried that was so unrealistic. It would have been nice if it were smaller bugs, lizards, small birds, hamsters, etc. that were smaller and wouldn't catch even if I hid them in my pocket... The foreshadowing related to the mystery of Shardock has not been collected, and the first part has been completed, but does that mean that it wasn't popular enough to make the second part?

  Helpful