Liar X Liar

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Jul 13, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English
  実写も観ました
  I also watched the live action
  This review contains spoilers. 正直最初は、弟と恋？って？と思って、読むのを拒否してました。実弟だと思ったので。でも、ＮとSを読んで、最後まで引き込まれたので、作者さんが好きで読み始めました。ただ湊が結局筋を通そうとしすぎて、周りを振り回しているのが気になりました。映画だと透はあまり悪い男という感じはしなかったのですが、漫画はえー⁈って思うほどに、酷い奴でした。結婚できるって分かってからも、脈がないと思って遊んでたのには、同情、うん、できなかったな。だって結局湊は純粋なままだったわけだから。で、思ったのが、みなはたまたまお姉さんだったからよかったけど、本物のJKを20歳の大学生が振ったら、JKの人生を弄んだ事になると思う。だから本当はあの時から薄っすら気づいていたのだとおもいたい。気づいていても、みなが何も言ってくれないから、透も湊本人と向き合うって決めたから、であってほしいなと思いました。NとSでもJKでしたが、本物のJKはもっと純粋で子供で物分かりなんかよくないと思う。ちょっとその辺が、サラッと流されすぎてて、あれ？って思いました。どなたかも書いておられましたが、結構重い内容だけど、絵の雰囲気がいいので、サラッとす読み進められたのだと思います。NとSも確かに重い内容だったけど、絵が可愛くてサラッと読み進められましたし。でも映画と違って詳細なので、いつかまた読み返してみようと思います。読み返して思う事何で？烏丸くんじゃダメだったんだろう？確かにみなとして透と会って、情は出てきてたし、兄弟としてもうっすら好感は持っていたとしても、過去の行いをあんなにスッキリ忘れて透と付き合う方を選んだ湊にはちょっと共感できないな。ちなみに、登場人物がほとんど阪急沿線の名前というのが親近感が持てます。京都線と宝塚線ですよね？

  This review contains spoilers. Honestly, did you first fall in love with your brother? what is it? I thought so I refused to read it. I thought he was my real brother. But when I read N and S, I was drawn in until the end, so I started reading because I liked the author. However, I was worried that Minato was eventually trying to get through too much and was swinging around. I didn't feel like Toru was a very bad guy in the movie, but he was so terrible in comics that I thought, um... Even after I knew I could get married, I thought I had no pulse, but I sympathized, yeah, I couldn't do it. That's because Minato remained pure after all. So, what I thought was that everyone happened to be older sisters, so I'm glad, but if a 20-year-old college student waved a real JK, I think they would have played with JK's life. So actually, I think I was faintly aware from that point on. Even though I was aware, everyone didn't say anything, so I wanted it to be because Toru also decided to face Minato himself. It was also JK in N and S, but I don't think the real JK is more pure, kid, and doesn't understand things well. that area was swept away a little too smoothly, huh? That's what I thought. Everyone wrote it, and the content is quite heavy, but the picture has a nice atmosphere, so I think I was able to read it smoothly. N and S were certainly heavy, but the pictures were cute and I was able to read on smoothly. But unlike the movie, it's detailed, so I think I'll reread it again sometime. Why do you think after rereading it? Karasuma-kun wasn't good, was it? Certainly, everyone met Toru, and feelings came out, and even though they had a slight crush on them as siblings, I don't sympathize with Minato, who so clearly forgot about his past actions and chose the one to go out with Toru. Incidentally, the fact that most of the characters are names along the Hankyu Line gives me a sense of familiarity. Kyoto Line and Takarazuka Line, right?

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Jun 18, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English
  1ページごとの密度が濃く最高！
  The density of each page is intense and the best!
  するするとお話が読みたくなる、暖かくて、優しい気持ちでキュンキュンする、大学生の頃の気持ちも思い出せて、幸せな気持ちになれます！映画を観た後に漫画を読みました！大好きです！

  Then you'll want to read the story, you'll feel warm and kind, and you'll be able to remember how you felt when you were a college student, and you'll feel happy! I read comics after watching the movie! I love it!

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Apr 17, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English
  ドキドキと欲望の配分が素晴らしい
  The distribution of excitement and desire is wonderful
  他人を演じて嘘をつく楽しさと、イケメンな義弟が実は自分の事が好きで…という嬉しいシチュが重なる美味しいお話。題材の割に終始あまり重過ぎず、大学生の頃を味わいながら楽しめる作品でとても良いです！

  It's a delicious story where the fun of playing someone else and telling lies overlaps with the happy situation where the handsome brother-in-law actually likes himself... It's not too heavy from beginning to end for the subject, and it's a very good work that you can enjoy while enjoying your time as a college student!

  Helpful