A NANNY FOR CHRISTMAS

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Mar 24, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English
  作画者様の言う通り
  The artist is right
  そもそものことの発端はヒーローに女性を見る目がないこと(-_-)元妻で懲りてるだろうに何故同じタイプの女性ばかりと付き合う？ヒーローの性格は自分過信の優等生が陥る型はめ盲信タイプの典型＋お育ちの良いお人好し....これはヒーロー娘の性格が遺伝的証拠（異母弟にはこの要素なし＆元妻に似なくって本当に良かった！）なのでかろうじて難を逃れているけれど、ヒーローはその悪縁を切り捨てられない。でヒーロー娘もそれの被害を被っているけれど、もっとも最悪な被害者はなんの関係もないヒロイン...間接的である彼女の人生の約4分の1を黒歴史にしたのはヒーローであることは間違いない?結果クリスマスを絡めたヒーローの隠れた罪の償いをHQらしく、内省的でクレバーで自分の境遇を誰のせいにもしない辛い達観の持ち主ヒロインが幸せになる物語でした。

  In the first place, the beginning is that heroes don't have an eye for women (-_-) why do they only date women of the same type when they are probably punished by their former wives? The hero's personality is typical of the stereotyped blind believing type that overconfident honor students fall into + well-raised friendliness... this is genetic evidence that the hero daughter's personality (my half-brother doesn't have this element & I'm really glad she doesn't resemble my ex-wife!) So they've barely escaped trouble, but the hero can't get rid of that bad relationship. So the hero daughter also suffered damage from it, but the worst victim was the heroine who had nothing to do with it... there's no doubt that it is a hero who indirectly made about a quarter of her life into black history? As a result, it was a story where the hero's hidden sins involved with Christmas made the heroine happy, who is introspective, clever, and has a painful Tatsugami who doesn't blame anyone for her circumstances.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  Feb 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English
  女運が悪いヒーロー
  A hero with bad luck
  This review contains spoilers. 元妻といい前ナニーといい、女性の見る目が悪すぎるヒーロー。ヒロインに対していつから恋をしたのかご微妙に思いました。

  This review contains spoilers. A hero with an ex-wife, a nice former nanny, and a woman's eyesight is too bad. I had a subtle feeling about when I fell in love with the heroine.

  Helpful

• 

  Posted by Readers in Japan

  May 02, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English
  読み応えあり
  It's a good read
  ヒロインの過去に何があったのか気になり過ぎたし、皆様のコメでヒーローがダメ男過ぎだと叩かれてたのも気になって購入。私はそこまでダメ男だとは思わなかったな。ちゃんと毎回謝ってるし、本人も女を見る目がないって反省してるし。考えずに言ってしまうという自分の欠点を自覚してて、それが治らないだけじゃん。他のHQ傲慢ヒーローなんて言いっ放しで最後にちょろっと謝るだけだぞ！それにしても、作者あとがきにもありましたが、ヒーローはただただ、美人な悪女や小悪魔系がタイプなだけだと思う。じゃあなんで真面目なヒロインに？という疑問は、やっぱ初対面の印象が悪女だったから、そこじゃない？って思ったわ。それにしても、ヒロインの過去の悪夢が、カルト宗教とかなのかと想像してたら全然違ったわ〜

  I was too curious about what happened in the heroine's past, and I was also curious about everyone's comedy that the hero was being slapped for being too bad, so I bought it. I didn't think I was such a bad guy. I apologize properly every time, and I'm also sorry that I don't have an eye for women. I'm aware of my own flaw of saying it without thinking, and it's just that it can't be cured. Just let go of the other HQ arrogant heroes and apologize a little bit at the end! Even so, as it was in the author's afterword, I think heroes are just beautiful villains and little devils. Then why a serious heroine? The question is, after all, my first impression of meeting her was a bad woman, so isn't that it? That's what I thought. Even so, when I imagined that the heroine's past nightmare was a cult religion or something, it was completely different ~

  Helpful