The Poor Lady and Her Wonderful Miscalculation Manga Reviews

Awags

Report

Jul 14, 2025 (PST) | Total Reviews: 133

Kinda boring

This review contains spoilers. There's not a whole lot to the story here and it's over pretty quickly, almost like it was a speed run. The set up for the meeting with the love interests plays out exactly like planned and they live happily ever after (i assume - haven't actually read the last chapter but read thru all the rest since I unlocked multiple at once which was a mistake)

They sorta tried to do something interesting with the brother's personality/motivations towards the end but it didn't really land since everyone got what they wanted.

I'd say read the first few and thats all you really need to get the gist of things, but save your money for something else

Helpful

(1)

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 07, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

何度も読みたくなる

Makes me want to read it over and over

This review contains spoilers. 貧乏男爵家の双子の姉弟が、お金目当てに侯爵令息と公爵令嬢の婚約に横やりを入れます。,,,と書くとすごい悪い二人に思えますが、全ては領民の生活ため、領地改革をする元手を稼ぐため。体を壊しかけてる姉のため。ええ子たち～！もうね、するする読めるんですよ。何度読み返してもページをめくる手が止まりません。お話もキャラも二転三転、最終話までドキドキします。リアルタイムで追っていった作品のひとつ。ただ農家としては一点、苗木植えたその年にこんなに実はつかんぞ(笑)

This review contains spoilers. A twin brother and sister from a poor baron family get engaged between the marquess's resignation and the duke's daughter for money. If you write,,, they seem like two really bad people, but all of them are for the sake of living in the domain and to earn money to carry out territorial reforms. for my sister who is about to destroy her body. yeah kids! That's enough, I'll do it, I can read it. No matter how many times I reread it, I can't stop turning the pages. The story and characters are twists and turns, and it's exciting until the final episode. This is one of the works I followed in real time. However, as a farmer, I didn't get this much fruit the year I planted the saplings (laughs)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 13, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

展開が目新しくて、ワクワクしました

The development was new and I was excited

This review contains spoilers. 貧乏男爵家の双子の姉弟が報酬を得て領民たちを守るため、恋愛結婚に憧れる侯爵子息と公爵令嬢につかのまの疑似恋愛を経験させるというとんでもないミッションを遂行しようとする展開が目新しくて、ワクワクしましたね〜。姿を消すことが確定しているので惚れてはいけない・・・けど、あんなに甘い時を共に過ごしてしまったらそりゃ惚れてまうやろ〜!ってね。まぁでもタイトルが「貧乏令嬢の素敵な誤算」ですからね、悪い方向に話が転ぶことはない=心穏やかに読み進んでいけるのがありがたいです。

This review contains spoilers. In order for the twin siblings from the poor baron family to obtain rewards and protect the people of the domain, the development of trying to carry out a ridiculous mission of making the marquis's son and the duke's daughter, who yearn for a love marriage, experience a ridiculous pseudo-romance was novel, and I was excited. It has been confirmed that they will disappear, so don't fall in love... but if they spend such a sweet time together, then they'll fall in love! I mean. Well, since the title is “The Poor Daughter's Wonderful Miscalculation,” I'm thankful that the story doesn't turn in a bad direction = I can read on with peace of mind.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 28, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

一気に２回読みました！

I read it twice in one go!

１回目は主人公の貧乏令嬢目線で。2回目は弟の目線で読みました。次は、侯爵令息目線で読もうと思っています。本当に素敵な誤算でした。

The first one is from the perspective of the main character, a poor young lady. The second time I read it from my brother's point of view. Next, I'm thinking of reading it from the perspective of Marquis Rei. It was a really nice miscalculation.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 13, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

いい話でした。

That was a great story.

最後まで読ませて頂きました。すごく素敵な話でした。この後の話が読めるなら読みたいです。是非是非短編でもいいので、よろしくおねがいします(*˘︶˘*).｡*♡

I read it to the end. It was such a wonderful story. If I can read the story after this, I'd like to read it. By all means, a short film is fine, so thank you (**) . .* ♡

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 08, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

幸せになって良かった‼️

I'm glad I'm happy ‼️

貴族は政略結婚が殆んどの中、姉弟共両思いで幸せになれて、実家も貧困から脱け出せたなんて素晴らしい‼️この物語終わりですか？

The aristocrats almost had political marriages, so it's wonderful that both siblings were happy and their parents' families were able to get out of poverty ‼️ Is this story over?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 06, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

素敵なおとぎ話?

A nice fairy tale?

This review contains spoilers. あるところに、貴族とは名ばかりの貧乏だが勤勉で心優しい双子の姉弟がいました。自分たちの食べ物にも困る暮らしの中、懸命に働きますが、一向に良くなる兆しもなく、いよいよ領民の暮らしも脅かされるほどになっていきました。そんな時、双子の姉弟に有力な貴族から信じられない依頼が舞い込みます。『婚約の決まってる貴族カップルのそれぞれの恋愛相手になってくれないか？依頼を受けてもらえれば多額のお礼を用意します！』どうやら巷では恋愛結婚ブームで、政略結婚を嫌がる二人に恋愛を経験してから結婚させたいと考えてのことのよう。心優しい二人は、人を騙すなんて…と悩みますが、領民の暮らしは待ったなし！命には代えられないと依頼を受けることにしました。貴族のカップルの二人は本当にお互いに恋愛感情がないようで、双子の姉弟はすんなり仲良くなっていきます。貴族の彼は、姉の純粋で一生懸命なところに惹かれ、積極的に好意を示してくれます。姉も彼の強引さが嫌でないよう。一方、貴族の彼女も勤勉で姉思いの弟に好感を持ち、弟も自分のことを尊重してくれる彼女を好きになっていきました。ところが、仲良くなった矢先に依頼主に告げられたことは『依頼は達成されました！成功報酬を差し上げますので別れを告げず、帰ってください！』悲しい気持ちを押し殺して去って行く二人の前に…?素晴らしいおとぎ話展開でキュンキュンしました?ネタバレしちゃうとつまらないので書けませんが、ラスト良かったですよ?短いのでサクッと読めて読後の余韻も良いです?おすすめ?

This review contains spoilers. Once upon a time, there were poor, hardworking, and kind-hearted twin siblings named nobles. While they were struggling with their own food, they worked hard, but there were no signs of getting better at all, and the lives of the people in the domain were finally threatened. At that time, an unbelievable request comes in to the twin siblings from an influential aristocrat. “Why don't you become romantic partners for each aristocrat couple who have decided to get engaged? If you accept the request, we will prepare a large thank you!” Apparently, there is a love marriage boom in the streets, and it seems that they want two people who don't like political marriage to get married after experiencing romance. The two kind-hearted people worry about deceiving people... but they can't wait to live in the domain! I decided to accept the request because it couldn't be replaced by my life. The two aristocrat couples really don't seem to have romantic feelings for each other, and the twin siblings get along easily. An aristocrat, he is attracted to his older sister's pure and hard work, and she actively favors him. My sister doesn't seem to like his aggressiveness either. Meanwhile, my aristocrat girlfriend also had a good impression of her brother, who is hardworking and older sister, and my younger brother also fell in love with her, who respected her. However, as soon as we became good friends, what was told to the client was, “The request has been fulfilled! We'll give you a success reward, so don't say goodbye and go home!” in front of the two who push their sad feelings to death and leave...? Were you thrilled by the amazing fairytale development? I can't write it because it's boring if there are spoilers, but the last one was good, wasn't it? It's short, so it's quick to read and has a good afterglow after reading? recommended?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 31, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

最後の最後まで素敵なお話しと絵でした。

It was a wonderful story and pictures until the very end.

これほど爽やかな気持ちで応援したくなる作品は少ないように思う。読了感も最高でした。またこの作者さん達のタッグで読みたいです。

I don't think there are many works that I feel so refreshed and want to cheer for. The feeling of reading it was also great. I want to read it with these authors again.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 11, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

誤算です

It's a miscalculation

本当に誤算でした。超ハッピーなんですが、あまりにも展開が早く、大きな山場もなくハッピーになっちゃいました。この先、何かあるんですか？

It really was a miscalculation. I'm super happy, but it unfolded so fast, and I became happy without a big mountain. Is there anything ahead?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 03, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

素敵！

nice!

今のところドロドロもなく、ニマニマ読めてます！絵も可愛いしカッコイイし、ストーリーも好き！なかなか購入しない私でも我慢出来なくて購入しました(笑)早く続きが読みたいです！！！

There's no mush so far, and I can read Nimanima! The pictures are cute and cool, and I love the story! Even if I don't buy it easily, I couldn't stand it so I bought it (laughs) I want to read more soon!!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 02, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

素敵な恋物語

A wonderful love story

素敵な恋物語です。信頼関係のある幼馴染と。仲良し兄妹と。幸せになって欲しいと願う弟と。10まで読み終えましたが、とても良かった。

It's a wonderful love story. With a childhood friend I have a trusting relationship with. With my brother and sister who are good friends. With my younger brother who wants him to be happy. I finished reading up to 10, and it was very good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 02, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

原作よりも

More than the original

This review contains spoilers. 原作読みました。スーッと読めておもしろかったです。コミカライズは絵が綺麗で繊細な感じで好きです。原作よりも内容が濃くなっていて、ステファンの思惑とか追加されていて厚みがあります。原作の方がキスは濃厚でしたけど（笑）登場人物がみんな優しくて瀬実でホッとします。原作もコミカライズも安心して読めます。おすすめです。

This review contains spoilers. I read the original story. I was able to read it quickly and it was interesting. I like Comicalize because the pictures are beautiful and delicate. The content is darker than the original, and Stephen's speculations have been added, making it thick. The kiss was more intense in the original story (laughs), but all the characters are kind and I feel relieved. You can read both the original story and the comicalization with peace of mind. I recommend it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 02, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

えーーー( ﾟДﾟ)

Eh (°°°)

This review contains spoilers. 今までとても楽しく読まさせていただきました。まさか、前回でこんなことになるとは、この展開、嘘だと言って～( ；∀；)。と、ショックを受けましたが、ちゃんと姉思いの弟でした。やっぱり、とても素敵な雰囲気を持ったよい作品です。

This review contains spoilers. I've enjoyed reading it so far. No way, if this happened last time, say that this development is a lie ~ (; tish;). I was shocked, but she was a brother who really loved her sister. After all, it's a good work with a very nice atmosphere.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 27, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ハッピーエンドで！

with a happy ending!

This review contains spoilers. 昔の時代にあっただろうなと思う社会背景。これからの策略が成功して、優しい姉弟がそれぞれ幸せになってほしいです！

This review contains spoilers. A social background that I think would have existed in the old days. I hope that the strategy from now on will be successful, and that the friendly siblings will each be happy!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 04, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

騙したのは悪いけど

It's bad that I cheated

This review contains spoilers. 領民のために婚約者同士の方たちと疑似恋愛をするのは心苦しかっただろうと思う。本当に好きになってしまい幸せになるのを願ってます。

This review contains spoilers. I think it must have been painful to have a pseudo-romance with my fiancés for the sake of the people of the domain. I really hope they will fall in love with you and be happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 04, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

あらぁ～(*゜Q゜*)

Aaah~ (*°Q°*)

This review contains spoilers. お二組ともかなり出来上がってしまってアツアツですねここで離したら執事さんかなり恨まれるよ‼️計画的とわいえ

This review contains spoilers. Both groups have been completed quite a bit and it's hot, right? If you leave here, the butler will be resented quite a bit ‼️ premeditated and awful

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 25, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

早く続きが…

It will continue soon...

試し読みで読んだら面白くて！気付いたから7巻までまとめて購入していてあっと言う間に読み終わってました?次巻が気になり今後の展開が早く読みたいです?

It was interesting when I read it as a trial reading! I noticed it, so I bought up to 7 volumes in bulk and finished reading it in a blink of an eye? Are you curious about the next volume and want to read future developments as soon as possible?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 22, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

一気読み！

Read it all at once!

クーポンがあったので試しに読んでみたら、ハマってしまって7巻まで一気買い！パートナーを交換して演技で恋愛するはずが徐々に本気に……。8巻早く！！

There was a coupon, so when I tried reading it, I got hooked and bought up to 7 volumes at once! They were supposed to exchange partners and fall in love through acting, but they gradually became serious... Volume 8 soon!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

ぎゃー！

huh!

7巻までまとめて読んだんですけど、はやく！早く次を読ませてくれっっ！1番面白いとこでー！！はよ！…と叫びたくなるぐらいイイです。正直そんなに期待せず読んだんですけど、絵もストーリーもそんなに派手さはないし、良作だなーって感じでそこまで…とか思ってたはずなんですけど、いやいやいやいや、ほんと読んで。てか早く8巻読ませて！

I read up to 7 volumes at once, but fast! Please let me read the next one as soon as possible! at the most interesting place!! haha! It's so good that it makes me want to scream... To be honest, I read it without expecting that much, but the pictures and story aren't that flashy, and I must have thought that it was a good work... but hey hey, really read it. Heck, let me read volume 8 as soon as possible!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 10, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

早く！

quickly!

早く続きが読みたいです！もう少したまってから読めば良かったなと思うくらい一気読みで物足りないです。

I want to read more soon! Reading it all at once is so unsatisfactory that I think I should have waited a little while before reading it.

Helpful

Reviews for The Poor Lady and Her Wonderful Miscalculation Manga