MangaPlaza

Sorry! You need an account to do that! Sign up now to get the most out of your MangaPlaza experience!

Register For Free!

Already registered?

All

Romance

MP Originals

Action

BL

Adult Romance

Yuri

Fantasy

Drama

Horror

Harlequin

Light Novels

|

Find Titles

Search Menu

Search by Genre

Explore Premium

New
Best Sellers
SALE
Coupon
Now Free

Search by Popular Keywords

Others

Search by Author

Special Collections

Reviews for A Certain Magical Index Manga

Overall :

4.7

24 Global Ratings

5 star

71%
4 star

29%
3 star

0%
2 star

0%
1 star

0%

1 - 20 of 24 Reviews

Sort by

Japanese reviews were originally posted on Comic C’moA. Some reviews may contain spoilers for unreleased content or topics unrelated to MangaPlaza services.

Translate All Reviews to English

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 29, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

魔術が街を救う

Witchcraft saves the city

This review contains spoilers. そちらの作品に関しましてはと言いましたらですと、昔アニメで話題になっておりますので存在自体は知っております。とある男子高校生がある日シスターと名乗る少女と出会い新たな人生が始まるというバトル漫画です。ただの男子高校生がなんならかの形で魔術を手に入れて街の危機を救うという展開はとても興奮しますし、主人公やその仲間たちを応援したくなります！

This review contains spoilers. Speaking of those works, they have become a hot topic in anime in the past, so I know they exist. It's a battle comic where a male high school student meets a girl who calls himself his sister one day and begins a new life. I'm very excited about the development where just a male high school student obtains magic in some form and saves the city from crisis, and I want to support the main character and his friends!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 04, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

ずっと好きな作品

Works I've always liked

This review contains spoilers. この作品を語る上では、やはり上条当麻は外せない。一見捻くれ者で無気力だが、目の前で困ってる人が居たら絶対に放っておかない。自分の痛みなんて顧みずに、病的に他人ばかりを優先して突っ走れる。前時代的な主人公像かもしれないが、やはりこういうのがいい。人を助ける事においてはひたすらバカ真っ直ぐな上条が大好きで、この作品を読み続けてしまう。

This review contains spoilers. Toma Kamijo cannot be missed when talking about this work. At first glance, they are twisted and lethargic, but if someone is in trouble right in front of you, never leave them alone. I can pathologically prioritize only others without worrying about my own pain. It may be an image of the protagonist from a previous era, but this is still nice. I love Kamijo, who is just stupid and straight when it comes to helping people, and I keep reading this work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 19, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

良作

Good work

ライトノベル『とある魔術の禁書目録』の漫画版ですね。ライトノベル版は刊行スピードが早いのと、こちらが月刊誌における連載ということもあって、ストーリー展開はかなり遅く感じてしまうかもしれませんが、その分かなり丁寧な仕上がりになっています。また、他の方も言われている通り、1巻から現在にかけて画力の向上が著しく(モサモサ上条さんからスタイリッシュ上条さんへ)、大変読みやすくなっていると共に読み応えもとてもあります。とてもお勧めです。

It's a comic version of the light novel “To Aru Magi: A List of Forbidden Books.” The light novel edition has a fast publication speed, and since this is a serialization in a monthly magazine, you may feel that the story development is quite slow, but the finish is quite careful. Also, as others have said, drawing power has improved markedly from volume 1 to the present (from Mosamosa Kamijo-san to Stylish Kamijo-san), making it very easy to read, and also very responsive. I highly recommend it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 10, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

アニメ化

animated

三期が残念な形に終わってレールガンのほうが人気が出てしまっている原作組なので漫画も頑張ってほしい

The third season ended in a disappointing way, and Railgun is the original group that has become more popular, so I want them to do their best with comics

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 06, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

アニメがめちゃくちゃ面白かったので、漫画を買ってみようと思います。

The anime was insanely interesting, so I think I'll buy comics.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 17, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

アニメから

From anime

まず電磁砲のアニメからとあるシリーズに手を出した口ですが、やっぱり本編を見ないとということで禁書目録も見始めました。でも、面白そうだということは分かるけれどもアニメだけだと理解が追いつかないので漫画読み始めました！やっぱり、分かりやすい！読んで正解です！やっぱり面白かった(^^)

First, I dabbled in a series starting with the electromagnetic cannon anime, but after all, I had to watch the main story, so I started watching The Prohibited Books List as well. But I know it looks interesting, but I can't keep up with my understanding if it's just anime, so I started reading comics! After all, it's easy to understand! Read it and you got it right! It was interesting after all (^^)

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 02, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

とあるシリーズ好き

I like a certain series

アニメの3期がいまいちだったので漫画版を購入しました。画力が以前より格段と上がっておりアニメより迫力があって文句なしですとあるシリーズはコミカライズに恵まれてますね

The 3rd season of the anime didn't go well, so I bought the comic version. The drawing power is much better than before, and it's more powerful than the anime, so there are no complaints. Some series are blessed with comicalization

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 09, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

感動した

impressed

This review contains spoilers. インデックスが可愛すぎ感動するアニメ声優も豪華です最高！

This review contains spoilers. The anime voice actors whose index is so cute and moving are also gorgeous and awesome!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 09, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

最高ｯｯ

awesome lol

本屋でたまたま立ち読みしたら、どハマリしてしまった作品です。特に一方通行が最高です!!最ｯｯ高のツンデレ(男だけどね…)です!!

It's a work I happened to read while standing in a bookstore, and I was so addicted to it. One-way traffic in particular is the best!! It's the most expensive tsundere (although it's a man...)!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 17, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

面白いですよ！

It's interesting!

漫画のほうが何度も見返せるし、理解を深めれる気がします。これ気にったらアニメもみてほしいです！こんな世界にすみたいなーw

I can look back at comics over and over again, and I feel like I can deepen my understanding. If you like this, I want you to watch the anime too! it's like living in a world like this lol

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 10, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

いいね❗

Nice ❗

アニメも面白かったけど、漫画の方が言葉の意味が分かりやすくて読みやすい！大満足な作品ですね?

The anime was interesting too, but comics are easier to understand and read! It's a very satisfying work, isn't it?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 31, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

めちゃくちゃ面白かったですよ。一度読んでみてくださいな。オススメです

It was insanely interesting. Please read it once. I recommend

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 31, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

面白かった

That was interesting

とても面白かったです‼︎アニメも面白かったしとてもオススメです

It was very interesting ‼ ︎ The anime was also interesting and I highly recommend it

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 10, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

絵が綺麗

The picture is beautiful

この漫画から入って原作の小説も読みましたが、異能力アクションがあるためやはり漫画のほうが分かりやすくて良いです。作画も綺麗なので非常に読みやすいです。できたら姫神の話も書いてほしかったな～と思います。

I started with this comic and read the original novel, but since there are actions with different abilities, the comics are still easier to understand and better. The drawing is also beautiful, so it's very easy to read. If it were possible, I think I would like the story of Himegami to be written too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 07, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

とある作品は

What is a certain work

元々好きでしたのでまた新鮮な気持ちで見れます、魔術けいなので、科学より魔術がすきなかたはおすすめします

I originally liked it, so I can watch it with a fresh feeling again; it's magic, so I recommend it if you like magic over science

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 26, 2013 (PST) | Translate to English

良い！

good!

やはり、アイディアはすさまじいですね内容はかなりしっかりしているし、深すぎるキャラもかわいいし、設定も詳しくされている文句なしです

After all, the idea is tremendous, isn't it? The content is pretty solid, the characters that are too deep are cute, and there are no complaints that the settings are detailed

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 22, 2013 (PST) | Translate to English

かっけぇ～

that's cool

This review contains spoilers. 上条当摩さんすげぇ～最強のレベル0だな（≧∇≦）あんな能力あったら誰にもまけんでしょ！アクセラレータも大好きです！

This review contains spoilers. Kamijo Toma is amazing ~ she's the strongest level 0 (≥), wouldn't it be a bonus for anyone! I love accelerators too!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 23, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

おもしろい！

It's interesting!

異能を無力化するという設定が面白いし、呑気な学園の様子とバトルのギャップもいい。無邪気なヒロイン、インデックスとクールな御坂の対比も良い！

The setting of neutralizing different abilities is interesting, and the gap between the relaxed state of the school and the battle is also nice. The contrast between the innocent heroine Index and the cool Misaka is also good!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 05, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

インデックス

indices

この作品は、キャラクターが多彩なので色んな物語が楽しめます。特に、ヒロインも多くみんな魅力的です。

The characters in this game are diverse, so you can enjoy a variety of stories. In particular, there are many heroines, and they are all fascinating.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 10, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

一方通行

one-way street

一方通行さんが好きでしたvというより百合子ちゃんが好きでした。。。当麻さんの説教が長いとよく言われるのを聞いて読んでると確かに長いですがまあ面白いのでセーフかな？

I liked Yuriko-chan rather than V who liked One-Way Street... If you listen to Toma's sermons often being said to be long and read, they're certainly long, but they're really interesting, so is it safe?

Helpful

Stay Connected!

Subscribe to
Our Newsletter
Add to
Home Screen
Our Premium
Membership
Instagram

Other Social Media：X | X(BL) | Facebook | Youtube | TikTok

Register For Free!