A Tunnel of Spring Rain Manga Reviews

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 21, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

切なく優しいお話

A sad and kind story

どっちかというと絵はあっさり目だけど、作品の雰囲気がとても好きな作家さん。2作品入っていてどちらも面白かったですが、タイトル作品の心の動きや切ない感じの描写が特に好きです。

As for which one, the artist has simple eyes, but he really likes the atmosphere of his work. There were 2 works, and both were interesting, but I particularly like the title work's depiction of the movement of the heart and the feeling of sadness.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 25, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

優しくてせつない。

They are kind and stubborn.

せつないお話が繰り広げられたいかなで。読んでいて、胸が苦しくなりました。でも旭君の友達がとても良いやつで、こんな友達持てて幸せだと思いました。お友達最高。

I wonder if a sad story would unfold. It made my heart ache as I read it. But Asahi-kun's friend is a very nice guy, and I thought I was happy to have such a friend. Your friends are the best.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 18, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない…

sad...

This review contains spoilers. 誰も悪くなくて、みんな優しくて、だから切ない。ハピエンだけど、ほろ苦い。亡くなった姉の彼氏でまだ結婚前だったから義理の兄弟でもなくて、ただの他人…。攻め受けどちらの気持ちも分かるから泣けました。でも二人が離れなくて良かった。年月がきっと癒やしてくれるはず。切ないけど受けが健気ですごく好きなお話で、胸に残りました。もう一つの短編もまた切なめで、大人な攻めが好みでした。

This review contains spoilers. No one was bad, everyone was kind, and that's why it's sad. Happy, but bittersweet. My older sister's boyfriend who passed away and he wasn't even married yet, so he's not my sibling in law, he's just a stranger... I was able to cry because I understood the feelings of both of them being attacked. But I'm glad they didn't leave. I'm sure the years will heal you. It was a sad but well-received story that I really liked, and it stuck in my heart. The other short story was also sad, and I liked the mature attack.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 25, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

すごく胸にしみた

It really seeped in my heart

This review contains spoilers. とっても切ない展開が続いて、旭と一緒に胸が痛くなります。でもやまない雨はないようにいつか青空が広がるように、二人の前途は幸せそうです。両思いになれて良かった、お姉さんも天国で絶対微笑んでます。

This review contains spoilers. A very sad development continues, and my heart hurts along with Asahi. But it seems like the blue sky will spread out someday so that it won't stop raining, and the future of the two seems happy. I'm glad I was able to get used to both of them, and my older sister is definitely smiling in heaven too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 05, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった

good

絵は特に好みではなかったけど、表題作の話がせつなくてすごく良かったです。この作家さんの「美容師の恋人」も好きです。

I didn't particularly like the picture, but it was really nice that there wasn't much talk about the title work. I also like “The Beautician's Lover” by this artist.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 26, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

好きな作家さん

Favorite authors

好きな作家さんです！絵の好みが分かれそうですが、ストーリーがしっかりしていてどの作品も好きです。

This is my favorite writer! They seem to have different picture tastes, but the story is solid and I like every work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 02, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった

good

結婚式前に姉が亡くなり、その弟と婚約者の話で切なかったですがハッピーエンドで良かったです。読んでいて弟の友達にも好感もてました。人が亡くなると誰もが後悔したり自分を責めたりしてしまうので BLなんですがこういう話は救いになると思います。もう1つの話も良かったです。

My older sister passed away before the wedding, and although it was sad to talk about her younger brother and fiancé, I'm glad it had a happy ending. My younger brother's friend also liked it while reading it. When people die, everyone regrets and blames themselves, so it's BL, but I think this kind of story will be a relief. The other story was good too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 24, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない

It's sad

よくあるストーリーだと思いますがとにかく切ない。途中読むのやめようかなと思ったくらい切なかった。最後安心できたよ。良かったよ。

I think it's a common story, but it's just sad. It was so sad that I thought I'd stop reading it halfway through. I was relieved at last. That was great.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 23, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない

It's sad

あまり絵が好みではなかったんですが、読んでみたらはまりました。切なくて胸がぎゅーってなります。受けを応援したくなります！エロは薄いですが内容がとても良いのでｵｽｽﾒです。

I didn't really like the picture, but after reading it, I fell in love with it. I'm so sad that my heart is tight. I want to cheer for receiving! It's not erotic, but the content is very good, so I recommend it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Sep 19, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

とても良かったです。

It was very good.

ストーリー展開がとても秀逸でキャラクターのそれぞれの持って行き場のない切ない感情や表情がとても良かったです。独自の雰囲気や個性的な作画が大好きな作家さんです。

The story development was excellent, and the sad feelings and expressions that each character had nowhere to go were very good. He is an artist who loves his unique atmosphere and unique drawings.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 13, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない話

A sad story

This review contains spoilers. 亡くした人には一生勝てない…ましてや姉。そんなつらい立場の受けが健気で切ない。でも、あっさり両想い展開ではなく、三年という二人の月日が描写されているのもいい。読み切り短編もよかったです。

This review contains spoilers. I can't beat someone I've lost for the rest of my life... let alone my sister. It's healthy and sad to be accepted in such a difficult position. However, it's also nice that the two dates of three years are depicted instead of an easy development of ambition. The short one-off story was also good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 13, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

亡くなった人には勝てない

You can't beat people who have died

って言うけど、弟としても姉を愛していたので切ない。彼女を忘れてほしいようなほしくないような気持ちに胸が苦しくなりました。お姉さんも許してくれると思います。

But it's sad because he loved my older sister as a younger brother. It made my heart ache as if I didn't want her to be forgotten. I think my older sister will forgive me too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 07, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

タイプの違う切ない話が２作品

2 sad stories of different types

ひとつめは義理の兄になるはずだったひとと高校生の話。ふたつめは刑事とサイコパスな男の子の話。どちらも切なくてしっとりとしたかんじです。この方の作品、結構好きなんだけど、ストーリー展開が絵柄と同じように、ちょっと雜になるようなところが残念に思うので星－１コ。

The first one is a story about a person who was supposed to be my brother in law and a high school student. The second one is about a detective and a psychopath boy. Both of them felt sad and moist. I like this person's work quite a bit, but I'm sorry that the storyline is a bit messy, just like the pattern, so -1 star.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 09, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

切ないけどハピエンですっごい好き

It's sad but I really like it in Happien

絵がちょっと雑？なのでマイナス1しましたがお話はすごく好き。旭がほんとにほんとにいい子だし理解あるお友達もグッド！いい子の友達はいい子。ただ先にキスしたのは英司なのにそこは言わなかったのかな？ちゃんとネタバレしてほしかった。刑事さんと人の心の声がきこえてしまう男の子のお話も好きでした。男の子の表情がすごく良かった。どちらもハピエンで大満足。

Is the picture a bit complicated? So I gave it minus 1, but I really like the story. Asahi is a really, really nice kid, and his understanding friends are good too! A good boy's friend is a good kid. I wonder if Eiji didn't say that even though the one they kissed first was just that? I wanted the spoilers to come out properly. I also liked the story of a detective and a boy who can hear the voices of people's hearts. The boy's expression was really nice. Both are happy and very satisfied.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 05, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

良かったです

That was great

This review contains spoilers. 泣けました。お姉ちゃんも喜んでいるんじゃないかな、それ位度量ある魅力あるお姉ちゃんだったんじゃないかなと、そう読んでてそう思える暖かさがあるお話でした。親はどうなのかな…うーん…でも真剣に悩んでくれそう。そう考えるとまだ乗り越えなくちゃいけないものはまだまだありそうだけど、幸せになって欲しいと、想像力膨らむお話でした。応援したくなる2人。また読みたいと思うお話でした。そして続編も。あー続編出ないかな。

This review contains spoilers. It made me cry. It was a warm story that made me think that when I read it, I think the older sister was happy too, and that she was an attractive older sister with that level of measure. I wonder what the parents are like... hmm... but they seem to be seriously worried. With that in mind, it seems like there are still more things we have to overcome, but it was a story that made my imagination expand because I wanted them to be happy. Two people I want to cheer for. It was a story I wanted to read again. And a sequel too. Oh, I wonder if there will be a sequel.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 26, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

姉の幸せを心から願えてるのもいい。

It's also good to sincerely wish for your sister's happiness.

姉の恋人に恋するストーリーって大体、姉に嫉妬して悩むパターンが多いけど、旭は姉も英二も大好きだし、二人の幸せを心から願ってたから、姉が亡くなった後も簡単に気持ちを伝えずに姉の代わりを3年し続けてたわけで、そこに罪悪感を持ってたりする優しい心の旭が健気に感じて英二と幸せにずっと居て欲しいと思いました。

Most stories about falling in love with an older sister's lover have a pattern of being jealous and troubled by her older sister, but since Asahi loved both her older sister and Eiji sincerely hoped for their happiness, she continued to replace her older sister for 3 years without easily conveying her feelings even after her older sister died, and I wanted Asahi, a kind heart that has a sense of guilt there, to stay healthy and happy with Eiji the whole time.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 08, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

せつなーい！

that's not bothersome!

えー悲しいけど何年かけてでも思いっきり幸せ！って思えるようになって欲しいな～ジンワリける作品でした！

Eh, it's sad, but I'm happy to the fullest no matter how many years it takes! I want you to be able to think that ~ it was an amazing work!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 08, 2015 (PST) | Translate to English

久々に…

after a long time...

銀川先生作品を読みました。絵は相変わらずでしたが(エラそうですいません)、切ないストーリーで、でもHAPPY ENDで、結果読後感よかったです。主人公は高校生。亡くなった姉の婚約者とのお話。あとがきにあった、某Sくんがいい当て馬で登場していたら、また一層切なさあふれてよかったかもしれないけど、「亡くなったお姉さん」という最強の存在があるから、この方がシンプルでよかったのかな。最初はただ大好きなお姉さんの恋人、ってだけで、この2人との空気感が好きで、それが、お姉さんが亡くなって、彼女の代わりに世話を焼いているうちに、いつの間にか好きになってた。でも自分はあくまでもお姉さんの代わり…という、旭の切なさがとても伝わってきました。お友達もいいヤツ！もうちょっとね〜、絵が安定するといいと思うんですけど、これがこの作者さんの味ともいえるので、☆4つです。エロは最後にちょっと。それでよかった。

I read Ginkawa-sensei's work. The picture was still the same (sorry for that), but it was a sad story, but it was a HAPPY END, and I felt good after reading the results. The main character is a high school student. A story with my sister's fiancé who passed away. If a certain S-kun, who was in the afterword, appeared as a good hit horse, it might have been nice to be even more sad, but since there is the strongest person called “the older sister who passed away,” I wonder if this one would have been simpler and better. At first, it was just my favorite older sister's lover, and I liked the atmosphere between these two people, but after my older sister passed away and while I was taking care of her, I fell in love with it before I knew it. But it really conveyed Asahi's sadness that I was just a replacement for my older sister... Your friend is a nice guy too! A little more, I think it would be nice if the picture stabilized, but this can also be said to be the artist's flavor, so it's ☆ 4. A little bit of eroticism at the end. I'm glad that was it.

Helpful

Reviews for A Tunnel of Spring Rain Manga