THE SHEIKH SURGEON'S PROPOSAL Manga Reviews

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 01, 2026 (PST) | Translate to English

ヒーローはこうでなくちゃ

Heroes have to be like this

This review contains spoilers. 身分や立場のせいで、王の座に着いたヒーローのために身を引くヒロインはよく見かけます。その場合ヒーロー側近が追い出し側だったりするのだけどこちらの側近は最後まで根気強くヒロインを引き留めてくれました。そしてヒーローも愛のために全てを捨てるのではなく関係者と交渉を重ねた上で身軽になりました。権力総動員でヒロインの居場所を突き止めたのも拍手です。

This review contains spoilers. It's common to see heroines who step down for heroes who have taken the throne due to their status or position. In that case, the hero's close aide was on the evicting side, so that close aide patiently held the heroine until the end. Also, the hero did not throw everything away for love, but became lighter after repeated negotiations with those involved. I also applaud them for finding out where the heroine is by mobilizing all powers.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 09, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

理想と現実の間での苦悩

Anguish between ideal and reality

愛を手に入れるためにはどんな犠牲も厭わないとは言うけれど、一国の王としてその器もある男性をその座を諦めて自分のそばにいてほしいとは言えないと思ってしまった。医師として命の重要さを分かっている人なだけによりそう思ってしまうのかもしれない。裕福な国とそうでない国との争いや伝統、思考の壁に苦悩しながらも医療を通じてその重責を肩に背負い、いずれは王としての責務に就かねばならないとはいえ医師としてあるとは強靭な精神力と体力が無ければ絶対無理！！！マレクは出来すぎなヒーローです。ウットリするより恐ろしいです。ジャナーンだってそう思っていたはず。国の「掟」はその国に暮らす人たちの法律なのだからジャナーンの立場では恐怖でしかなかったでしょう。それでもマレクはジャナーンとの未来のために必死に戦ってくれている姿はトキメク以上に胸が痛くなりました。

They say they are willing to make any sacrifices in order to attain love, but as the king of one country, I thought it would be impossible to say that I wanted a man who possessed that power to give up that position and stay by my side. Maybe they think so just because they are people who understand the importance of life as doctors. While struggling with disputes, traditions, and barriers of thought between wealthy countries and countries that aren't, they shoulder that heavy responsibility through medical care, and even though they eventually have to take on responsibilities as king, it's absolutely impossible to be a doctor without strong mental strength and physical strength!!! Marek is an overpowered hero. It's scarier than outrage. Janan must have thought so too. Since the “law” of a country is the law of the people living in that country, it was probably nothing but fear from Janan's point of view. Even so, the sight of Marek fighting desperately for the future with Janan made my heart ache more than thrilling.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 10, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

王位か恋か

Is it the throne or love

女性ならほぼ誰でも、全てを捨てても自分だけを愛してくれる人を望む。自分が愛している人が、そこまで自分を愛してくれる、これ以上の女の幸せはないだろう。それだけ、現実はままならない。ストーリーはまさに夢を体現するかの様に格好良く終わる。絵は全く好みではないが、二人の状況設定や自立した考え方など随所にひかれる要素があり、気にならなかった。もっとも、マレクがスーツ姿で袖まくりする絵は私の好きなポーズであった。事故現場に救急に駆けつけて髭を剃り損ねた顔は、疲労のためにこけた頬のラインも貧相となり、そういう場面では仕方がないのだが、状況に忠実なことに驚かされた。だが、最初からちゃんとまっすぐヒロインに寄せている愛情があり、ヒロインのことを考えての行動をマレクが取り続けることに、読んでいて私は状況に酔わされ、多少好みでない絵であろうと、王位を賭けた世紀の恋を連想させられ、ちょっとした夢気分になれるのだ。ただ放り投げたのではなく、ちゃんと問題を片付けた、というキャラも好感度上がる。人の命を救う、そういう姿は無条件に素敵に感じてしまう、というのもある。

Almost every woman wants someone who loves only herself, even if she abandons everything. The person she loves loves herself so much, and there is no greater happiness for a woman. That's all, reality won't stay the same. The story ends in a cool way, as if embodying a dream. I don't like the picture at all, but there are elements that attract me everywhere, such as the situation settings of the two people and their independent way of thinking, so I didn't care. However, the picture of Marek rolling up his sleeves in a suit was my favorite pose. The face that rushed to the scene of the accident and failed to shave her beard had a poor cheek line due to fatigue, and it was unavoidable in such a situation, but I was surprised that it was faithful to the situation. However, there is a love that has been directly attached to the heroine from the beginning, and since Marek continues to take action thinking about the heroine, I am intoxicated by the situation while reading it, and even if it is a picture I don't like, it reminds me of love in the century where they risked the throne, and it makes me feel like a bit of a dream. The likability of characters who didn't just throw it around and cleaned up the problem properly also increased. There is also the fact that such a sight of saving people's lives makes me feel unconditionally wonderful.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 09, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

愛の成せる技

The Art of Love

愛の為、自分の本当にやりたいことの為に王位を捨てられるヒーローって素敵。ヒロインも愛情深い女性で素敵でした。

A hero who abandons the throne for love and for what he really wants to do is wonderful. The heroine was also a lovely, affectionate woman.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 29, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

いい！

That's good!

最高に良くまとまった作品です。女性は純粋で賢く、男性も彼女を良く理解してます。だいぶ前に購入していましたが何度も読み返してます。

It's a superbly well-organized work. The woman is pure and smart, and men understand her very well. I bought it a long time ago, but I've reread it over and over again.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 27, 2013 (PST) | Translate to English

密だっ

It's dense

素晴らしい…画風が綺麗なうえ、表情がスゴく良く、内容や構成が密でとても巧いっまるで小説を◎ﾏﾙっと一冊読んでいるよう流れが淡々としてなくて躍動感がある書き方だからかな～ｽﾄｰﾘｰは、自分のﾙｰﾂをとﾀﾞﾑﾎｰﾙに来たﾋﾛｲﾝ、ジャナーンが世界援助機構GAOの医師面接に向かう途中、交通事故でDr.マレクに出会うのですが、彼ははなんと！出会い頭から大災害が起こり慌ただしく、2人は救援活動へ…その間に益々、引かれあう2人ですがマレクの素姓が明らかに自制する2人ですが、ある出来事でタガが外れてしまい愛を誓いますそんな時に国王の死去。ジャナーンは自分の素性やマレクとマレクの国の為に…ﾋﾛｲﾝが可愛い顔で勝ち気なのでｽﾊﾟｲｽが効いてますかくて、一難去って又一難、…んっ？今度は何?ﾅﾆ?って紆余曲折を経て2人の愛は、う～ん、マリク男らしい主人公達の織りなす思いが切々と伝わり最期の最後まで気が抜けないお話でﾄﾞｷﾄﾞｷです以前、尾方琳さんの『愛と憎しみの迷宮』を（ﾀｯﾀ6話）読んで以来の凄く、面白いと思った作品ですしかし…、私はザイードの方が好きだぁバックで一押しです

It's amazing... the style of painting is beautiful, the facial expressions are so close, and the content and structure are so clever; it's probably because it's a writing style that has a sense of dynamism without the flow being blunt and has a sense of dynamism. Story is a video where she comes to the gym, and Janan is on her way to an interview with a doctor at the World Aid Organization GAO, and he meets Dr. Marek in a traffic accident, but what is he! A major disaster occurred from the beginning of their encounter, and the two went to relief activities... during that time, they are 2 people who are drawn more and more, but they are 2 people whose real surname Marek clearly restrains them, but due to an incident, their taga came off and they pledged their love. At that time, the king died. Janan is good for her background and the country of Marek and Marek... since Viroin has a cute face and a winning spirit, so space works, so after one difficulty, it's another difficult... huh? what next time? Nah? After going through twists and turns, the love between the two is, well, it's a story where the interwoven feelings of Malik's masculine protagonists are completely conveyed and you can't lose your mind until the end. Previously, I thought it was an amazing and interesting work since reading “The Labyrinth of Love and Hate” by Rin Ogata (episode 6), but... but... I like Zayed better, I recommend it in the background

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 09, 2013 (PST) | Translate to English

ありえないっ！

that's impossible!

現実的にはありえないっ！けど、二人が微笑ましくて涙出てくる！フィクションだと分かってるけど、二人の今後がずっと幸せならいいな、なんて思ったりしちゃってます?絵が綺麗で、話の展開やテンポもいいし、物語に引きずりこまれました?話は長めだと思いますが、もっともっとこの世界に入っていたかったな〜?ってぐらい早く過ぎ去ってしまいましたよ！ポイント払っても全然無駄にならないし、私の説明じゃ上手く伝わらないので、是非是非御一読ください！！

Realistically, that's impossible! But they both smile and burst into tears! I know it's fiction, but do you think it would be nice if the two of them were always happy in the future? The pictures were beautiful, the story development and tempo were good, and you were drawn into the story? I think this is a long story, but I wanted to enter this world even more~? It went by so fast! Paying points won't be wasted at all, and my explanation doesn't convey it well, so be sure to read it!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 19, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

とてもよかったです

It was very good

気持ちがきちんと描かれているので、ヒーローヒロインの性格もわかりやすかったです。何度も読み返してしまうくらいの作品です。

The feelings were properly depicted, so it was easy to understand the personality of the hero heroine. It's such a work that I reread it over and over again.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 03, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

大好きな

I love it

シークものです。しかもシークでさらに医者ときたもんだ。もう完璧です！ただ、絵がちょっと古い感じがしたのが残念。お話はとても良かったです。

It's a seek thing. What's more, I got even more doctors in Seek. It's already perfect! However, it's a pity that the picture was a bit old. The story was very good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 15, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

ヒーローがいい！

Heroes are good!

ハーレクインにありがちな傲慢なだけの王族ヒーローではなく、医者でもありヒロインにたいしても誠実なヒーローが素敵でした。子供の性別聞いたときのセリフがまた素敵でした。

It wasn't just an arrogant royal hero that Harlequins usually have, but a hero who was also a doctor and was honest with his heroine was wonderful. The line I had when I asked the child's gender was also wonderful.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 22, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

カッコイイ！ジャナーン(*´ω｀*)

cool! Janan (*'ω`*)

ジャナーンはヒロインです。でも、なんて男前なヒロインなんでしょう( 〃▽〃)?初見ではレビューをしませんでしたが読み返してみて改めて書きたい気持ちにかられました。なんたってジャナーンが医師としても女性としても素晴らしい人物。知的で正義感が強く美しい。そしてそして、お相手のマレクもそんな彼女に相応しく、王族としての偉大さや責任感はありながらも決して尊大な態度を取らない出来たお方なのであります。そんな二人が織り成す物語、面白くないはずがありません。じゃあ、なぜ☆４つかと言えば、前半から中盤にかけての盛り上がりに比べると後半がやや失速気味に思えてしまうため。意外性やなるほどーな感じはあったんですがワクワクするような面白味にかけた気がするのです。もっと脇役を上手くつかったりして終盤の盛り上げが可能だったはず。。主人公たちの魅力は物凄かったけど、やっぱりお話って脇が重要。最後までどっぷり読ませるには欠かせないピースです。あのヒゲのお付きの人とかもっと味つけしちゃえばよかったのにー……なんて、欲張りなこと思っちゃうのは途中までが最高に面白いからですね。とはいえ、全体的にはストーリーも面白くスピード感もあるので大変面白く読めました(^ ^)vおすすめっす⤴

Janan is the heroine. But what a handsome heroine (▽▽〃)? I didn't review it at first sight, but after rereading it, I felt like I wanted to write it again. Janan is a wonderful person, both as a doctor and as a woman. They are intelligent, have a strong sense of justice, and are beautiful. Also, her partner, Marek, is suitable for such a girlfriend, and she is a person who never took an arrogant attitude even though she had a sense of greatness and responsibility as a member of the royal family. There's no way that a story woven by these two people isn't interesting. Well, speaking of why ☆ 4, the second half seems to have stalled slightly compared to the excitement from the first half to the middle. There was an unexpectedness and a sense of wonder, but I feel like I put on it in an exciting and interesting way. It should have been possible to raise the excitement at the end of the game by taking on supporting roles even better... The appeal of the main characters was amazing, but after all, sides are important when it comes to stories. It's an essential piece for making them fully read to the end. I wish I had added more flavor to that bearded person... the reason I think being greedy is because halfway through is the most interesting part. Nonetheless, overall, the story is interesting and there is a sense of speed, so it was a very interesting read (^ ^) v I recommend it ⤴

Helpful

Reviews for THE SHEIKH SURGEON'S PROPOSAL Manga