Imperfect Girl Manga Reviews

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 15, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

幼女こわい…

I'm afraid of little girls...

幼女が青年を拉致拘束するというトンデモ設定ですがストーリー展開と絵の見せ方が非常に上手く続きが気になり過ぎて一気に読みきってしまいました。

It's a tone-demo setting where a young girl abducts and detains a young man, but the story development and the way the pictures are shown were so good that I was so worried about the continuation that I read it all at once.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 21, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

名前から

From name

名前から気になってて見たら、もう、、少女のかんじかなんとも言えなくて好きです

I'm curious from the name, and when I see it, I like it because I can't say anything about the girl

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 14, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

よかったです

I'm glad

This review contains spoilers. 経済的に裕福だけど、普通の愛情を受けて育ってない子どもは、その逆より悲惨だと思う。そして冴えない男子学生だと思っていた主人公の少女に対する考え、行動がかわっていく様（彼自身、葛藤もたくさんするが）や、レールから脱線してもそこそこ楽しく面白く生きれるし、幸せになっちゃいけないほどではない。といろんな話の中に含ませて少女に話して聞かせている姿に、人の気持ちや痛みがわかる優しい人だと思った。ラストの再会で大人になった少女の明るい表情が、彼との出会い（作品を含めて）がいいものだったことを物語っている。もちろん彼にとっても。

This review contains spoilers. I think children who are financially well-off but don't receive normal affection are more miserable than the opposite. Also, it seems like the main character's thoughts and actions towards the girl, who I thought was a dull male student, are changing (although he himself has a lot of conflicts), and even if he derails from the rails, he can live a reasonably fun and interesting life, and it's not like he shouldn't be happy. I thought she was a kind person who understood people's feelings and pain by including them in various stories and talking to the girl. The bright expression of the girl who became an adult at the last reunion shows that her encounter with him (including the work) was a good one. Of course for him too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 06, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

よかった

That was great

よがつたかねりよかつたよ部隊と京都やしなかなかよなったありがと

Yogatsu Takaneri Yokatsuta Yo Troop and Kyoto got along pretty well thank you

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 27, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

あり得なさそうで、あり得そうな物語！

A story that seems like a good deal, and it seems likely!

This review contains spoilers. 最初の二人の出会いのシーンが一番印象的でした。そこからまさか大学生の男性が小学生の女の子に拉致されるとは、予想外でした。女の子の凶器的な性格や言動に震えながら、少女の家庭を青年が悟っていくうちに少女の家庭の状態がどんどん知っていく時はホラー映画を見ているようにドキドキしていました。そんなストーリーにあわせて背景の魚のような影や少女の妖艶な姿が物語を引き立てていました。

This review contains spoilers. The scene where the first two met was the most impressive. It was unexpected that a college student man would be abducted by an elementary school girl from there. While trembling at the girl's lethal personality and actions, it was exciting as watching a horror movie when the young man became aware of the girl's family more and more about the state of the girl's family. In line with such a story, the fish-like shadows in the background and the girl's bewitching appearance enhanced the story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 21, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

二度目

Second time

別のサイトでも読んだので二度目です。少女に脅されて、逃げられる瞬間があるにもかかわらず、大人しくついていく青年の気持ちに共感しました。深淵を覗くとき、深淵もまたこちらを覗いている。たとえ殺されることになっても、その瞬間は今しかないと思ったら、結末を知りたいと思うのが人間の嵯峨なのかも知れません。ズレた感想でした。だけどおすすめ、面白いよ。

I read it on another site, so this is my second time. I sympathized with the young man's feelings of being threatened by a girl and following along quietly despite having moments where he was able to escape. When you look into the abyss, the abyss are also looking at here. Even if you end up being killed, if you think that moment is only now, it may be the Saga of Man that you want to know the ending. That was a misplaced impression. But I recommend it, it's interesting.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 22, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

面白い

interesting

絵も好みで、ストーリー展開も上手く、次が気になり一気見しました。もし作者の実体験に基づいて居たのだとしたら、奇妙、奇遇に尽きます。女の子がミステリアスながら可愛かったので、サクサク読めました。

I liked the pictures, the story development was good, and I was curious about the next one, so I watched it all at once. If it were based on the author's actual experience, it would be all strange and bizarre. The girl was mysterious yet cute, so I was able to read it quickly.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 12, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

素晴らしいコミカライズ

Great comicalization

原作小説の大ファンで、コミカライズされたときは狂喜しました。やはりラストに期待していましたが、納得、いや大満足のラストの描写でもうムネアツでした。心臓がしんどいです。

I'm a big fan of the original novel, and I was overjoyed when it was comicalized. After all, I was looking forward to the last one, but I was already so excited about the depiction of the last one that I was convinced or very satisfied with. My heart is tired.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 01, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

楽しめる

I can enjoy

少し怖いけれどおもしろかったです。時々出てくる話している側の視点や、少女の秘密を知りたくなるし、案外純粋というか素直な少女と主人公のやりとりもおもしろかったです。原作は読んだことがありませんが、表現の仕方などに惹かれました。

It was a little scary, but it was fun. It made me want to know the point of view of the speaker that comes up from time to time and the girl's secrets, and the surprisingly pure, or rather straightforward interaction between the main character and the girl was also interesting. I haven't read the original story, but I was attracted to the way it was expressed.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 31, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

斬新過ぎる！

That's too novel!

This review contains spoilers. 小学生に拉致された男性ですが、逃げることはいくらでもできたのに、少女の話を聞き、一緒に話し葛藤し少女に語りかけることが凄いと思います。斬新で面白く感動出来ました。少女が成長した後に再開し、男性に幸せそうに笑いかけるので締めくくるのも作品全体をよくさせますね。

This review contains spoilers. It's a man abducted by elementary school students, and even though he was able to escape as much as he wanted, I think it's amazing to listen to the girl's story, talk and struggle together, and talk to the girl. It was novel, interesting, and I was moved. It starts again after the girl has grown up, and it makes the man laugh happily, so concluding it also makes the whole work better.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 05, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

好きですねぇ

I like it

良い！めちゃくちゃ良い！少女と、もうひとりの方との掛け合いが好きすぎる。だし、自分が同じ状況下にいたらしんどくてなにも行動できないなーと。ラストが少し気に食わなかったので★4

good! insanely good! I love the interaction between the girl and the other person too much. Also, if I were in the same situation, it would be too difficult for me to do anything. I didn't like the last one at all, so ★ 4

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 18, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

独特の世界

A unique world

This review contains spoilers. 女の子が大学生の男性を誘拐するのはファンタジーとしても、閉じ込められた大学生が徐々に女の子の生活を知っていくのは面白かった。最初は女の子、表情や行動から勿論、怖い…と感じるけど、彼女の生活・裏側、どうしてそうなったのか、が暴かれて行くうちに女の子を守ってあげたくなるし、切なくて何とかしてあげたくなるし、胸にくるものがある。大学生と同じ気持ちになった。

This review contains spoilers. Even though it's a fantasy for a girl to kidnap a college man, it was interesting for a trapped college student to gradually learn about a girl's life. At first, of course, I feel scared... from the girl's facial expressions and actions, but as her life and the other side of her life and why this happened is revealed, I want to protect the girl, I'm sad and want to do something about it, and there's something that sticks to my heart. I felt the same way as college students.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 06, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

おおー

Oooh

はっとりみつる先生の作品は「いぬねこジャンプ」や「うみしょー」を読んでいて、元気はつらつ！可愛い女の子のイメージだったので今作のコミカライズはとにかく驚きました。雰囲気が全然違うので。でもとてもよかったと思いました。

I read Hattori Mitsuru sensei's works “Dog Cat Jump” and “Umisho,” and my energy is hard! It was an image of a cute girl, so I was really surprised by the comicalization of this work. Because the atmosphere is completely different. But I thought it was very good.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 02, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

無理やり感はあるけど私は好き

It feels like it's being forced, but I like it

This review contains spoilers. 人によって受け取り方や考えが違うので好き嫌いが分かれる物語だと思います。確かに、少女の為に主人公は逃げたり通報したりすべきだとは思うけれど逃げずに少女の人となりを知ろうとしていたところや自分が少女にしてあげられる事を彼なりに考えてやっていたのかなと思います。最後はハッピーエンドで安心しました。恋愛というよりは戦友？同志に近い関係になれそうですね。

This review contains spoilers. I think it's a story where likes and dislikes are divided because people have different ways of receiving it and thinking. Certainly, I think the main character should run away or make a report for the girl, but I think he was thinking in his own way about trying to get to know the girl's personality without running away and what he could make a girl himself. I was relieved to have a happy ending at the end. comrades in arms rather than love? It looks like we'll be able to have a close relationship with friends.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 14, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

小説から

From a novel

タイトルに惹かれ小説を読みました。当時の私には難しく途中で断念しました。今になって漫画が出ていることを知り、読んでみました。やはり漫画だと見やすく理解も追いつきやすいです。現実味がある話で引き込まれます。

I was attracted to the title and read the novel. It was difficult for me at the time, and I gave up halfway. I learned that comics are out now, and I read them. After all, comics are easy to read and understand, and easy to catch up with. I'm drawn in by a realistic story.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 05, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

とても良かった

It was very good

文庫本を読んでからこちらの漫画を読みました。漫画なのでとても分かりやすく見やすかったです内容はもちろん絵も良かったと思います。

I read this comic after reading the paperback book. Since it's a comic, it was very easy to understand and read. Of course, I think the content was good too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 19, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

ぞくぞくしました

I was thrilled

This review contains spoilers. 西尾維新さん原作という事で興味を持ち購入。可愛いUの画はもちろんよかったのですが、何より両親の死体にゾクッとしました。ストーリーも画も満足のいく作品です。

This review contains spoilers. I was interested and bought it because it was an original work by Nishio Ishin. Of course, the cute picture of U was nice, but above all, I was horrified by my parents' dead bodies. The story and pictures are satisfying.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 08, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

不十分すぎる

It's too insufficient

ジャケットに惹かれて一巻読んでみた！最初から、少女の行動がいかれてて面白かった。

I was drawn to the jacket and read one volume! From the beginning, it was interesting to see how the girl acted.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 07, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

しんみり

Shinmiri

絵も綺麗で、ぐんぐん話にひきこまれます。少女の行動の理由には、胸がいっぱいになりました。

The pictures are also beautiful, and I am drawn into the story. My heart was full of reasons for the girl's behavior.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 24, 2016 (PST) | Translate to English

普通

ordinary

こんな少女いたらいやだ（笑）でも話にひきこまれちゃいます。絵も普通にきれいです。

I don't want to have a girl like this (laughs), but I'm drawn into the story. The pictures are also usually beautiful.

Helpful

Reviews for Imperfect Girl Manga