THE GROOM'S DAUGHTER Manga Reviews

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 04, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

胸キュンな物語

A heart-pounding story

お話の設定が少し複雑で、途中読み返したりしながらでしたが、とてもよく出来た物語でした。ヒロインの心情を考えると胸キュンする場面もいくつかあったし、ヒーローが最初はやな奴と思ったけど、最終的には愛しているからこそヒロインの本心をよく見抜いてくれて、ハッピーエンドに繋がりました。さすが汐宮先生、よくまとまった1冊でした！

The setting of the story was a bit complicated, and I was rereading it halfway through, but it was a very well-made story. There were a few scenes that made me cringe when I thought about the heroine's feelings, and at first I thought the hero was a bad guy, but in the end, they were able to see through the heroine's true intentions very well precisely because they loved them, leading to a happy ending. As expected, Shiomiya-sensei, it was a well-organized book!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 27, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

良いお話でした

That was a good story

This review contains spoilers. 誤解されたままなのに会話が成り立ってしまう。最後までハラハラしました。

This review contains spoilers. The conversation still holds up even though it remains misunderstood. It was jarring until the end.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 22, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

素敵な話

nice story

This review contains spoilers. 自分の父親を知らず親の愛情を感じず育ったヒロインが一目自分の父親に会いたくて訪れヒーローに愛人と疑われ接しているうちにお互いが惹かれ合いそれでも事実を告げられない切なさをキメ細やかに表現されている。オススメの1冊です

This review contains spoilers. The heroine, who didn't know her own father and grew up without feeling the love of her parents, visited her father at first sight, and while being questioned by the hero as her mistress, they were attracted to each other, and the sadness of not being able to tell the truth is expressed in detail. This is one book I recommend

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 07, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

綺麗

It's beautiful

絵が綺麗で、立ち読みからストーリーにも引き込まれて購入しました。購入して良かった作品です。

The picture was beautiful, and I was drawn into the story from the stand-up reading and bought it. I'm glad I bought this work.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 19, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

良かったねぇ

That was great

何度読んでも泣けるストーリーです。やっと実父と会えたニーナに良かったネ、と涙ポロポロです。相手を思いやって去った実母はどんな思いを抱いたのか、悲しいですが、事実を分かって良かったし、皆はやっと幸せになれて、と涙が止まりませんでした。

It's a story that will make you cry no matter how many times you read it. I'm in tears saying that it was great for Nina that I was able to finally meet my biological father. I'm sad about what kind of feelings my real mother had when she left because of her partner, but I'm glad I understood the facts, and everyone was finally happy, and I couldn't stop crying.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 06, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

泣。

crying.

不覚にも最後泣いてしまいました。人はやっぱり愛されて、愛して生きるのが一番ですね。

Unbeknownst to me, I cried at the end. After all, people are loved, and it's best to live in love.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 23, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

泣いた

wept

みんないい人ばかりでしかもハッピーエンド、言うことなし。汐宮ゆきさんの描く「手」がすごく好きです、顔が描いてなくても手だけで心情がわかります。マニアックですみません(^_^;全作品買いましたよ！新刊楽しみにしてます。

Everyone was nice and had a happy ending, nothing to say. I really like the “hands” drawn by Yuki Shiomiya, and even if I don't draw a face, I can understand the feelings with just my hands. Sorry for being a maniac (^_^; I bought all the works! I'm looking forward to the new publication.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 19, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

良かった

good

すごく好きな話。お父さんと会えた所からずっと涙が…流れは王道パターンだけど、それでいい。

I really like this story. I've been crying ever since I met my dad... the flow is a royal pattern, but that's fine.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 09, 2018 (PST) | Translate to English

よかった

That was great

親世代、子世代でちょっと複雑な関係になりますが、そこだけ押さえられていれば大変良いお話です。大好きなお話です。

It's a bit complicated between parent generation and child generation, but it would be a very good story if only that was kept in check. It's a story I love.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 23, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

まさに完璧！

Exactly perfect!

This review contains spoilers. HQコミック、物語に何かが足りないと思うことがけっこうあるんですが、この作品は内容が充実、不足感は全くなかった。それどころか、ヒロインが雷に怯えるシーンは心情が悲しいくらい伝わって来て、ジワッとくるくらいです。パパと対面するシーンもそう。HQコミック読んで泣くとは思わんかった……

This review contains spoilers. There are quite a few times when I think something is lacking in HQ comics and stories, but this work was full of content, and there was no sense of inadequacy at all. On the contrary, the scene where the heroine is frightened by lightning conveys feelings to such an extent that it makes me feel sad, and it makes me cringe. So is the scene where I meet my dad. I never thought I'd cry reading HQ comics...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 13, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

親世代がかわいそう・・・

I feel sorry for my parent generation...

This review contains spoilers. ニーナママは短い一生だったけど、ニーナパパも人生で一番、いい時をムダにした。ようやく自由になった時には、おじさんになってしまった。許してもらえなかったとか言っているけど、誰の許可が必要だったのかな？親族がうるさいなら、妻が跡継ぎを産まないのも、まずいのでは？

This review contains spoilers. Nina's mom had a short life, but Nina's dad also wasted the best time in her life. When I was finally free, I became an old man. They say they didn't get forgiveness, but who did they need permission from? If relatives are noisy, wouldn't it be bad for a wife not to give birth to an heir?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 26, 2017 (PST) | Translate to English

読んでじーんときた

I read it and read it

This review contains spoilers. 実のお父さん探しにきたら、愛人が追いかけてきたと勘違いされて、と出だしの段階でどんな内容になるのかと思っていたら、ストーリー自体は終始穏やかな感じで進んでいきました。お父さんとやっと会えたときは感動！！レンタルしたけど、購入してもよかったなぁ。

This review contains spoilers. When I came looking for my biological father, I was mistaken that my lover was chasing me, and when I was wondering what kind of content it would be at the beginning, the story itself progressed peacefully from beginning to end. I was so moved when I finally met my dad!! I rented it, but it would have been nice to buy it.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 04, 2014 (PST) | Translate to English

感涙が!!

I'm in tears!!

家族ものの感動ストーリーがメインな感じ…のラブストーリー♡と、イマイチ意味わからないこと書いてますが、読んだらわかる!!ラストはホント、(´;ω;`)ﾌﾞﾜ~ｯと涙が溢れました!!そして、レビュー書かずにはいられませんでした!!オススメです

It's a love story ♡ where the emotional family story is the main one... and it's written that I don't really understand the meaning, but if you read it, you'll understand!! The last one was really, ('; Ω; `) Wow, tears overflowed!! And I couldn't help but write a review!! I recommend

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 12, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

どうなるか気になります

I'm curious what's going to happen

完璧なエピローグが待っているのですね、だったらニーナもわざわざイギリスから実の父を探しに来た甲斐がありますね。

The perfect epilogue awaits, so it's worth it for Nina to go all the way to find her biological father from England too.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jul 26, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

ほぅ

Whoa

This review contains spoilers. 養父母に育ててもらったものの、期待には応えられず、また抱きしめられたりキスしたり、雷が怖いときもそばに居てもらうことも無い。こんな中で実父親の存在を知り、はるばるとイタリアまで。散々な目にあってるときに遭遇したのはなんと、、、、父親の過去の恋愛と不幸な結婚、相手の彼女も結婚して息子を、その後、過去の恋人との娘もできたのに、ずっと本妻は離婚に応じず親子三人はNew York暮らし。本妻の死亡により事態は動き出したのだけれど、子どもを産む事も拒否して、夫は昔からの恋人との間に子どもが居て。この本妻のエピソードはあまり出てこなかったけれど、頑ななだけなのかその強靱さは何処から来ていたのだろう。最後の納まり方が予定調和かもしれないがこの場合はベスト。

This review contains spoilers. I was raised by my foster parents, but they didn't meet my expectations, and they didn't hug or kiss me, or stay close to me when I was afraid of lightning. Under such circumstances, I learned about the existence of my biological father, and traveled all the way to Italy. What I encountered when they were in trouble was... my father's past love affair and unhappy marriage, my partner's girlfriend also got married and had a son, and after that, even though they had a daughter with a past lover, my real wife never responded to the divorce and the three parents and children lived in New York. The situation began to unfold due to the death of his real wife, but he also refused to have children, and my husband had a child with his old lover. There haven't been many episodes of Honma, but I wonder where that strength came from, probably because she's just stubborn. The final way to settle may be in harmony with the schedule, but in this case it's best.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 18, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

素敵なお話でした

That was a wonderful story

絵が本当に美しくて、ストーリーもとてもドラマチックで楽しめました

The pictures were really beautiful and the story was very dramatic and I enjoyed it

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Feb 20, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

泣けたけど

It made me cry

This review contains spoilers. H Qの王道のハッピーエンド。ヒロインの生い立ちを思うと最後は涙が出てきました。でも、他の方のコメントにもあったように、実父とヒーロー母の再婚までの流れはヒロインの母を思うとどうしても可哀想過ぎて、私には大満足とはいきませんでした…

This review contains spoilers. HQ's royal happy ending. When I thought about the heroine's upbringing, I burst into tears at the end. However, as others have commented, the process leading up to the remarriage between my biological father and my hero mother was just too pitiful when I thought about the heroine's mother, and I wasn't very satisfied...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 26, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

ヒロインは複雑な立場

The heroine is in a complicated position

のなか、元々の性格が善良だからか誤解され酷い扱いを受けても、よく忍耐しみんなに迷惑がかからないようにしていて、ヒロインの気持ちを思うと涙が出てきました。でも、報われ幸せになりました。登場人物すべてがハッピーエンドです。

Among them, even though she was misunderstood and treated harshly, probably because her original personality was good, she persevered very well and made sure not to cause trouble to everyone, and tears came out when I thought about the heroine's feelings. But it paid off and made me happy. All of the characters have happy endings.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 19, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

主人公は好きだけど

I like the main character

This review contains spoilers. 実の父に会いに来たヒロインとヒロインを愛人と誤解するヒーロー。それでもヒロインが好きだと言うヒーローは素敵だし、再会シーンは感動し養父母ともわだかまりがとれよかった☆と思ったけど、読み直すとヒロイン母が可哀想すぎ！ストーリーはよかったけど、女性を数名不幸にしたヒロイン父にうーん…となりました。

This review contains spoilers. A heroine who comes to see her biological father and a hero who misunderstands the heroine as her mistress. Still, the hero who says he likes the heroine is wonderful, and I was moved by the reunion scene and thought it was nice to get in a mess with my foster parents ☆, but when I reread it, I feel too sorry for the heroine's mother! The story was good, but it became hmm... to the heroine father who made a few women unhappy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 13, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

仲を引き裂かれた恋人が遺した子

A child left by a lover whose relationship was torn apart

This review contains spoilers. 訳あり旅人の尋ね人は、結婚を控えている。愛人と思っていたら、文無し女は問題行動は起こさない。その様子に真意がわからない。だが会いたいという意思は固そうだ。親の反対、名家の子どもは自分の結婚相手を、純粋に感情で選べない。父親が結婚相手を指図してきて結婚したなんて話、私の世代もないことじゃない。悲劇は過去のものとなっていき、二人の想いが形となった子どもが、二人の想いが確かなものだったと、ここに在るんですと、肉親の愛探しに、迷い出て訪ねてくる。ストーリーは、彼が実子であったなら、ヒロインと恋愛出来ないし、彼がそこまでヒロインを遠ざけ警戒する動機がないと、彼の居宅に足止めされる理由にならない。ストーリーの人物配置は手が込んだように見えるが、メイン二人の状況を優先させるとこうなるだろうというもの。彼が余り素敵に見えない。どちらかというとモサ男に見えなくもない。妹は可愛らしいのに。ビジュアル重視の私には重大な問題点だった。だが、そのために星を落とすことはしない。雑でなければよいのだ。また、旅先で困っているのを助けられる、というよくある類型で開始のこのストーリーには、彼が探している人に繋がる位置にいる人だった、という偶然を、物語進行の縦軸として差し込んでいる。ヒロインとヒロインの父との間の秘密を、家族崩壊を恐れてヒロインが胸の中にしまい続けている間に、HQに散見されるタイプの誤解が始まりだった先入観の主が、ヒロインと恋愛感情を育ててしまう。母子なんだな、そんなところ、と思わせる。自分がひとつの家庭を壊したりなんて出来ない、というところ。また、絵の才能で、父娘受け継いだものをもしっかり感じ取らせ、名乗り出られぬ娘の葛藤と隠しきれない血の繋がりを、読み手は目撃させられる。もどかしく読み進め、いつどんな形で対面するのかドラマへの期待は高まる。ヒロインのお母さんが気の毒でならない。夫と子と家族を成す喜びは遂に手に出来なかった。あまりにあっけない一生の開花期。彼女はHQ流ハピエンの恩恵に浴さなかった。それゆえヒロインも得られるはずのものから遠ざけられた。なんとなくヒロインの幸が足りない気分で一杯だ。今は亡きお母さんの分も取り返すような、もっと大きい深い満足感を得たかった。エピローグは私には｢完璧｣とは感じにくいものだった。

This review contains spoilers. For some reason, the traveler asked is about to get married. If you think of her as a mistress, a woman without a letter won't cause problematic behavior. I don't understand the true meaning of that situation. But they seem determined to meet. Opposing parents, children of famous families cannot choose their marriage partner based on pure emotion. It's not that my generation didn't live without a story where my father ordered a marriage partner and got married. Tragedies have become a thing of the past, and the child, whose feelings have taken shape, wanders out and visits when they are here, looking for love from their immediate family. The story is that if he is a biological child, he can't fall in love with the heroine, and if he doesn't have the motivation to keep the heroine far away and be wary, it's no reason to be stranded at his house. The character arrangement in the story seems elaborate, but this is what would happen if the situation of the main two people were prioritized. He doesn't look very nice. If anything, he doesn't even look like a Mosa man. Even though my little sister is cute. This was a serious problem for me, who emphasizes visuals. But we don't drop stars for that. It doesn't have to be messy. Also, in this story, which starts with the common type of being able to help someone in trouble while traveling, the coincidence that he was a person in a position to connect to the person he was looking for is inserted as a vertical axis of story progression. While the heroine continues to keep secrets between the heroine and the heroine's father in her chest for fear of family collapse, the main preconceived notions that began the type of misunderstandings scattered around HQ develop romantic feelings with the heroine. It makes me think it's a place like mother and child. It's a place where I can't destroy a single family. Also, with her talent for painting, she can clearly sense what father and daughter have inherited, and readers can witness the conflict between a daughter who can't come forward and a blood connection that cannot be hidden. I read on with frustration, and expectations for the drama are growing as to when and in what form they will face each other. I don't feel sorry for the heroine's mom. At last, I couldn't get the joy of having a husband, child, and family. The blooming season of a lifetime didn't come too soon. She didn't benefit from HQ style Happien. Therefore, the heroine was also kept away from what she was supposed to get. Somehow I felt like the heroine wasn't happy enough. I wanted to get a greater, deeper sense of satisfaction, like getting back for my now-deceased mother. The epilogue didn't feel “perfect” to me.

Helpful

Reviews for THE GROOM'S DAUGHTER Manga