Because You're Gone Manga Reviews

Saw12

Report

Sep 26, 2024 (PST) | Total Reviews: 14

Yaaaalllll

That was absolutely, so incredibly, super duper emotional. it was short but was seriously a Great read.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 19, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

ほっとした

relieved

This review contains spoilers. 最後、笑顔が見られてほっとしました。かけらを集めてくっつけてもいい。痛みがむき出しのままよりずっといい。日本には金継ぎって修復法もあるくらい、新しい味のある器になるのだし。生きていけるように縋りついて！

This review contains spoilers. At the end, I was relieved to see her smile. You can also collect the pieces and stick them together. It's much better than having the pain bare. It will be a vessel with a new flavor, to the extent that there is a kinkugi restoration law in Japan. Hold on so you can live!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 05, 2025 (PST) | Translate to English

これは恋愛なのか！？

is this love!?

年齢差が実はかなり大きいけど、こんな恋愛もありなのではないでしょうか。これは、法律的にも多分大丈夫ですよね。でも、恋愛なのか、寂しさの穴埋めなのか、まだ微妙な所はありますね。。

The age difference is actually quite big, but I think this kind of love is also possible. This is probably fine legally, isn't it? But there are still some subtleties about whether it's love or whether it's filling the gap in loneliness...

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jan 11, 2023 (PST) | Translate to English

愛する人を

A loved one

This review contains spoilers. 先に亡くした時どうなるんだろう。ましてや子供もいなくて独り残されて抜け殻になっちゃうよね。欠片を探してしまう気持ちわかるなー。子供に面影を探すように。幸せになってほしいです?

This review contains spoilers. What will happen if you lose it earlier? What's more, they're left alone with no children and become an empty shell. I understand the feeling of looking for fragments. Like searching for vestiges of children. Do you want them to be happy?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 15, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない物語

A sad story

悲しいけど素敵なストーリーでした。自然に涙が出るぐらい感情移入してしまうほど夢中になって読める作品でした。

It was a sad but wonderful story. It was a work I was so engrossed in reading that I was so empathized with it that I naturally burst into tears.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Apr 15, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

泣けました•••

It made me cry •••

誰もが経験するかも知れない今ある幸せが壊れたら••• を考えさせられました。ガツンときました！！大切な人を亡くして1人になったら、前に進める気がしません。義弟が言った一言にすがりたくなった紫音の気持ち••• 間違っていると思っていてもわかりました。

It made me think about... if the happiness we have now, which everyone might experience is broken... I was so excited!! I don't feel like moving forward when I lose a loved one and I'm alone. Shion's feeling that made me want to stick to a word her brother-in-law said ••• I understood it even though I thought it was wrong.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Mar 13, 2021 (PST) | Translate to English

泣いた、泣けた！！

I cried, I was able to cry!!

This review contains spoilers. 久々に号泣した。大切な人を共有していた二人が一緒に生きてゆく、羨ましく乙女になった。また、恋がしたくなった。

This review contains spoilers. I cried for the first time in a while. The two, who shared an important person, lived together, and became envious maidens. I wanted to fall in love again.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 24, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

難しいテーマだけど

It's a difficult subject

丁寧にラストに持っていっていて、読後感が良いです。昔は長男が亡くなったら次男が嫁を引き継ぐ、なんて話もあった気がするし、別に異常だとは思いません。そこに気持ちがあって血が繋がってないのならなんの問題もないでしょう。

I carefully brought it to the end, and it feels good after reading. I feel like in the past, there was talk of the second son taking over the wife when the eldest son died, and I don't think it's abnormal. If those feelings are there and they aren't related by blood, then there probably isn't any problem.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 21, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

涙でる

I'm in tears

This review contains spoilers. 夫をなくして、可哀想な話だけど、義理弟くんがなんとも、けなげで、素敵だったラストは、はっきりしてないけど、ハッピーエンドだと、思ってます

This review contains spoilers. Losing my husband is a sad story, but the last one where my brother-in-law was so damn nice is unclear, but I think it's a happy ending

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Jun 15, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

切ないけど愛おしい

sad but adorable

This review contains spoilers. 晃生がカッコよ過ぎる！！愛する人の死は残された人にどんな悲しみを遺すのか。その乗り越え方がセンセーショナルではあるものの最後読み終えた時に応援したくなるような2人になっていました。

This review contains spoilers. Kosei is too cool!! What kind of grief does the death of a loved one leave to those left behind? Although their way of overcoming it was sensational, they were two people that made me want to cheer them on when they finished reading them for the last time.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

May 09, 2020 (PST) | Translate to English

凄く良かった?

was that really good?

レビューの中には厳しい意見もありますが、私はとても切なくて、引き込まれて泣きました。私が初めてレビューを書こうと思った作品です。色々考えずに無心で読んでみて下さい。完結してますが、その後の２人の話も読んでみたいです。?

There are some harsh opinions in the reviews, but I was so sad that I was drawn in and cried. This is the first work I thought I'd write a review about. Please read it without thinking too much. It's complete, but I'd like to read the story of the two after that too.?

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 19, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

いろんな感情が入り交じります

A lot of emotions are mixed

とにかく切ないです。いろんな人生があると思うけど、何を選択するか、それが正解かそうじゃないか、誰も決められないし、誰も責められない。せめて、幸せになってほしいですね。

Anyway, it's sad. I think there are all kinds of lives, but no one can decide what to choose, whether that's the right answer or not, and no one can blame them. At the very least, I want them to be happy.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 17, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

大人

grownups

色んな人生私なら主人公さんに止めたいけど同情もしたくなる漫画でした

Various Lives It was a comic I'd like to stop the main character, but I also wanted to sympathize with it

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 16, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない・・

sad...

大好きな人と結婚して、いつまでも二人でいたいと子供つくる事を拒否してしまい・・でも最愛の人を若くして亡くしいなくなってからの後悔。弟くんと色々この先ありそうですが読んでいて切ないです。先が気になりますが幸せになってほしいな～

I married someone I loved, and I refused to have children because I wanted to be together forever... but I regret losing my loved one at a young age. There seems to be a lot ahead with my little brother, but it's sad to read it. I'm worried about the future, but I want them to be happy~

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 22, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

切ない

It's sad

This review contains spoilers. 最愛の夫を失った主人公と、夫の弟のお話です。大好きな人を喪った悲しみから、共鳴するように、ふたりは関係を持ちます。弟は主人公に好意を寄せているようだけれど、主人公の気持ちがどうなっていくか、これからの展開が楽しみです。できれば、主人公と弟くんには幸せになってほしいのですが。玉城先生の絵は色気や切なさがあって大好きなのですが、カラーがイマイチなのが残念です。肌の色が白くて病的なので、ちょっと怖いです。

This review contains spoilers. This is a story about the protagonist, who lost her beloved husband, and her husband's younger brother. The two have a relationship that resonates from the grief of losing someone they love. My younger brother seems to be fond of the main character, but I'm looking forward to seeing how the main character's feelings will turn out. If possible, I would like the main character and his brother to be happy. I love Tamaki sensei's paintings because they have sex appeal and sadness, but it's a pity that the colors aren't good. My skin is white and morbid, so I'm a little scared.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 06, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

切ないけど見届けたい

I'm sad but I want to watch

大好きな人を亡くした哀しみ、そこから一歩も動けないツラさにもがく主人公が、この先どうなっていくのか、とっても気になります。ていうか、義弟君にキュン❤︎

I'm really curious about what will happen in the future for the protagonist, who struggles with the grief of losing someone he loves and the hardships of not being able to move even one step from there. I mean, thank you for your brother-in-law ❤ ︎

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Nov 01, 2019 (PST) | Translate to English

切ないけど行く末が気になる

It's sad but I'm worried about the future

This review contains spoilers. 絵が綺麗で見入ってしまいます。夫が亡くなり、唯一残った仕事場を一生懸命守っていこうとするなかで夫の弟とある理由から関係を持つようになり…。弟くんの本当の気持ちも気になります。今後に期待…！！

This review contains spoilers. The picture is beautiful and makes me stare at it. My husband passed away, and while trying hard to protect the only remaining workplace, I began to have a relationship with my husband's younger brother for a reason... I'm also curious about my brother's true feelings. Looking forward to the future...!!

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Dec 26, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

弟

brother

This review contains spoilers. 妻と亡くなった旦那さんの弟のお話です。ふたりとも晃太のことが大好きでいいなと思う。旦那さんとの子どもがほしいから弟と…っていうところがいびつな感じだけど、関係自体は別にいいんじゃないかなあ。3年もふたりで悲しんできたわけだし。いろんな思いが絡まって複雑になっちゃってるふたりの心境をよく描けていると思います。

This review contains spoilers. This is a story about my wife and her deceased husband's younger brother. I think it's good that they both love Kota. The fact that I want children with my husband, so with my younger brother... is odd, but I wonder if the relationship itself is fine. The two of us have been sad for 3 years. I think it's a good depiction of the feelings of these two people, whose various thoughts are entangled and complicated.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Aug 12, 2024 (PST) | Translate to English

こんな愛の形も

This kind of love too

This review contains spoilers. 放題できれいな表紙に惹かれて。最愛の夫を亡くしたヒロインと、夫の弟。夫の欠片を求めて傷を癒し合う2人が切なくもあり、互いでしか癒やせない哀しみを感じました。絵が美しくて、より切ない雰囲気が出てました。短いですが、より掘り下げで2人の恋を読みたいと思えるような好みの設定、絵でした。

This review contains spoilers. I was attracted to the pretty cover with unlimited freedom. The heroine lost her beloved husband and her husband's younger brother. The two were sad as they were healing each other's wounds in search of a fragment of their husband, and I felt a sense of sorrow that only each other could heal. The picture was beautiful, and the atmosphere was even more sad. It's short, but it was a favorite setting and picture that made me want to read the love between two people in more depth.

Helpful

Posted by Readers in Japan

Report

Oct 29, 2022 (PST) | Translate to English

いいのでは？

Isn't that okay?

This review contains spoilers. 喪が開けてないうちからだったらちょっと待てと思うけど、3年も経ってるのだから別に、亡くなった旦那の弟と恋に落ちたっていいのでは？しきりにおかしいおかしいと責め立てる同級生の当て馬の男が気持ち悪かった。結ばれてからもストーカー化しそうだし、周囲にあることないこと言いふらしそう。あの男の存在がなければ面白い話でした。こういう形の幸せがあってもいいと思う。

This review contains spoilers. If mourning hasn't started, I think I'll wait a bit, but since 3 years have passed, isn't it okay to fall in love with my deceased husband's younger brother? I didn't feel comfortable with my classmate's guitarist, who was constantly blaming me for being strange. They seem to be stalkers even after they get tied up, and they seem to be fooling around. It would have been an interesting story without that man. I think it's okay to have this kind of happiness.

Helpful

Reviews for Because You're Gone Manga